The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

Dec 1991



The Dominion Sunday Times
December 15, 1991.

Sex abuse victims say male counsellors harassed them
by Amanda Cropp

Health professionals are angry about several cases where sexual abuse victims have been sexually harassed by male counsellors.

They are also worried about the number of poorly trained counsellors working in the sexual abuse field and suspect that some people prolong counselling to make extra money from accident compensation payments.

The Health Alternatives for Women group in Christchurch keeps a file of comments on counsellors and during the past year has received allegations of sexual misconduct by three men.

The allegations were backed up by two experienced sexual abuse counsellors.

In one case a man asked sexually intrusive and voyeuristic questions. He hugged the woman and rubbed against her when she had made it clear she did not want physical contact.

In another cast a counsel or breached ethical standards by having a sexual relationship with a client after her professional visits had ceased.

Both women were too frightened to lay official complaints or even to reveal the names of the men


Qualified

A counsellor said a male counsellor who was the subject of sexual abuse allegations was professionally qualified and still in practice. Another was confronted about his sexual relationship with a client and had stopped work.

Accident Compensation Corporation sexual abuse counsellors are vetted carefully. Several counsellors have been removed from the approved list after allegations of sexual harassment

The Association of Psychotherapists has received complaints but president Jan Currie said many of them concerned people who were not association members.


Vulnerable

She said women in counselling for sexual abuse were vulnerable and it was unacceptable for a counsellor to have a relationship with a client even if therapy had ended. The association was un happy that anyone could legally use the title counsellor.

Health Alternatives spokeswoman Korinne Stevenson said corporation approved counsellors were generally better than others, but a lot of good practitioners had long waiting lists.

This meant there was a risk victims would seek help from "fringe” counsellors who lacked proper training, were not part of a professional organisation with a code of ethics and did not work under supervision

Ms Stevenson said some people seemed to regard sexual abuse counselling almost as a money-making venture and charged a fee on top of the compensation payment.

The corporation has tightened its rules on sexual abuse counselling and requires a written report every 20 sessions.

Counsellors must justify the need for more than 60 Sessions.