The Christchurch Civic Crèche Case

News Reports Index

1996



The Evening Post
February 22 1996

Judge praised for fairness, humanity


Neil William Williamson, High Court Justice: b Christchurch, Dec 9, 1938; m 1962 Maree Jean Rondel; 2s, 4d; d Christchurch, Feb 14, 1996.

Justice Williamson was admitted to the bar in 1961 after completing his law degree at the University of Canterbury. He was a crown prosecutor with law firm Raymond Donnelly from 1968 to 1985.

He was also a former president of the district law society and vice-president of the New Zealand Law Society in 1984 and 1985.

He had a particular interest in the development of free legal advice centres and served as a judge advocate in courts martial. He was a member of the St Johns Ambulance Association subcommittee and a member of the Catholic Social Services consultative committee.

Justice Williamson, former executive High Court judge of the South Island, was remembered by colleagues as a man of impeccable fairness.

Christchurch High Court staff described Justice Williamson as a wonderful man, genuinely interested in people and proud of his family.

He was appointed a High Court judge in 1985 and presided over a number of high-profile court cases including the Christchurch civic creche indecencies trial of Peter Ellis and the Dunedin murder trial of David Cullen Bain. He had spent the last year as a judge on the criminal appeals division of the Court of Appeal.

Fellow judges paid tribute to Justice Williamson's national reputation for fairness. Executive High Court judge for the South Island Justice Tipping said his friend was one of the few who could combine a human touch with toughness and firmness when required.

High Courts sitting in Christchurch and Wellington and a number of District Courts around New Zealand adjourned briefly in respect of Justice Williamson.

Justice Hansen said his colleague was a warm and kind-hearted humanitarian with impeccable fairness. This fairness was recognised by the Court of Appeal which, in delivering its judgment on the appeal of David Cullen Bain, said of Justice Williamson:

"Having considered the evidence and the submissions of counsel in this case we (the court) do not doubt that the judge was meticulously fair in his summing up to the jury. This fairness extended to the judge's answers to questions from the jury where the judge was openly concerned to present the jury with a balanced and complete answer."

Justice Williamson would be an enormous loss to the High Court, the legal profession and the public, Justice Hansen said.

President of the Criminal Bar Association David Ruth said Justice Williamson was a pleasure to appear before and considered a very just judge. He would be sadly missed. He died, aged 57, shortly after a heart bypass operation.