The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports

2000 Index





Otago Daily Times
Thursday, 2-March 2000

Commissioner's call `premature'
NZPA Staff Correspondent

Wellington: Justice Minister Phil Goff yesterday dismissed a call for a child advocate in the Peter Ellis inquiry as premature.

Mr Goff said there was no decision yet on whether to conduct an inquiry into Ellis' conviction for child abuse or, if there was one, what form it would take.

Mr Goff is awaiting advice from officials on whether an inquiry into the Ellis case should be a royal commission or a scaled down ministerial inquiry.

Children's Commissioner Roger McClay said yesterday Ellis' victims had the right to be heard and the Government should appoint someone to speak on their behalf if an inquiry was launched.

"It is of grave concern to me that over the past six-and-a-half years since Ellis' conviction for sexually abusing children, public attention has been focused almost exclusively on the campaign to clear Ellis' name," Mr McClay told a Wellington Rotary club.

"In the midst of all this, the evidence of the child victims and their families has been largely ignored. The media and the public seem ready to discredit the evidence of these seven children and the many others who have since spoken out about their abuse at the hands of this man."

Mr McClay plans to raise his concerns at a meeting with Mr Goff on Monday, after a meeting with the parents of children from the Christchurch Civic Creche case.

However, Mr Goff said the commissioner should have waited until they had met before speaking out.

"The fact is it's not sensible to advocate a child advocate to any inquiry until we know whether there is an inquiry and what nature it will take.

"I think his comment was premature from that perspective."

Mr Goff also disputed the commissioner's "presumption" that he had not taken any account of the views of the families of the children involved in the creche case.

"I met last Friday with three of the families, giving them an equal amount of time that I gave to Mr Ellis' advocate and lawyer Judith Ablett Kerr." - NZPA