The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports

2000 Index





Otago Daily Times
Monday, 13-November 2000

Dunedin author in dispute over book
By Margot-Jane Smith

A book on the controversial Peter Ellis child sex case will not be published by Canterbury University Press after a dispute with the award-winning Dunedin author.

Canterbury University Press managing editor Mike Bradstock said Lynley Hood's book, A City Possessed , had exceeded the length stipulated in her contract but Ms Hood would not agree to it being cut.

Mr Bradstock confirmed Ms Hood's contract had been terminated but was not prepared to discuss the matter.

Ms Hood (57), who has spent the past seven years working on the book, would not comment on the reasons behind the dispute either.

"My silence doesn't necessarily imply that I accept what the publisher has said . . . I just don't want to get into a public dispute," she said. "I respect Canterbury University Press as publishers, and feel goodwill towards them, and regret."

She would not comment on the future of the book other than to say it would "definitely" be published.

In a February interview with the Otago Daily Times , Ms Hood said the book was not about reaching conclusions but an attempt to make sense of apparent contradictions and puzzles surrounding the Ellis case.

Peter Ellis was convicted in 1993 of abusing children in his care at Christchurch's Civic Childcare Centre.

He was released in February after serving two-thirds of a 10-year sentence and has always maintained his innocence.

His trial divided Christchurch people into those who believed the abuse had happened and those who believed the allegations were a result of parental hysteria and flawed police investigation.

Retired Chief Justice Sir Thomas Eichelbaum is conducting an inquiry into the best practice for investigating mass allegation sexual abuse cases and to determine whether these practices were followed in Mr Ellis' case.

His report is due in August.

Ms Hood's previous books include Minnie Dean , about the Winton "baby-farmer" who was the only woman hanged in New Zealand for murder.

The book was short-listed for the New Zealand Book Awards in 1994.