North and South
January 2002
(publication
date December 10, 2001)
Letters
Page 12
Unwarranted and Ill-Informed
In my many years
in publishing I have been involved in a number of controversies aired in the
media and despite the frustration that poor journalistic research arouses, I
have always felt it best to maintain a dignified silence. The unwarranted and ill-informed attack on
my sister, in Lauren Quaintance’s November article on Lynley Hood’s book has,
however, led me to change my position.
The report Anna
wrote was confidential, prepared solely for the publisher, at his request. The purpose of such a report is to honestly
examine the potential of a manuscript, taking into account the target market,
the style and standard of writing and research, given that the target market,
public interest, legal risk and a host of other factors.
Also for the
record, Bodyjamming was published in Australia three years before I
moved across the Tasman. The bizarre
and tenuous “connection” made by the writer between the publication of this
book and allegations of “hot-headed feminism” on the part of my sister is
therefore entirely without a factual basis.
There are no
direct quotes from my sister in the article other than those carefully selected
from her report, because your writer made no real attempt to interview
her. Even politicians are given a right
of reply, but it would appear this journalist believes fairness and regard for
a reputation that has been build over 25 years should not be allowed to stand
in the way of a good story.
Should your
magazine care to undertake some professional research you would find Anna’s
reputation as an editor is second to none in this country. She has worked with authors every day of her
professional life, and I can say with absolute confidence that every one of
those writers would voice their respect and admiration for her, both
professionally and personally.
Your magazine has
decided to cast doubt upon an impeccable reputation without even the right of
reply. Shoddy journalism at best,
vindictive at worst. You should be
ashamed.
Sydney,
Australia