The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2002 Jan-June Index



The Press
April 24, 2002

Police pursue abuse claim to two others
by Yvonne Martin

Police are widening their investigation into the latest complaint laid against Peter Ellis to cover two other people the complainant claims also abused him.

A young Christchurch man laid a formal complaint in January 2001 alleging that he was sexually abused by Ellis and others when he was a boy at the Christchurch Civic Childcare Centre.

The complainant, now 20, was not party to the original police inquiries in 1992-93 which resulted in Ellis being sentenced to 10 years jail for his conviction on 13 charges of abusing children in his care.

Police say they have obtained a legal opinion suggesting that the similar nature of the allegations made the possibility of fresh charges being laid against Ellis unlikely, given the fact that he had already served a sentence.

Police child abuse unit manager Detective Sergeant Chris Power said the police were guided by that legal opinion, but other people may be criminally liable in the case.

"He (the complainant) has alleged that two others were involved," Mr Power said.

"An important part of our investigation will be establishing their identity."

Mr Power said that once inquiries were completed, the unit would make a recommendation to police managers about whether to proceed with legal action against any other individual.

The family of the 20-year-old complainant, who recently married, have been advised by police not to comment.

Kathryn Johnston, co-ordinator of the Support Network for Parents and Caregivers of Sexually Abused Children who is supporting the family, said they were frustrated over the time the case was taking.

"They are trying to be patient. They have been reassured that there is an ongoing process, but it is obviously an incredibly slow one," she said.

Dunedin author Lynley Hood, whose book A City Possessed called into question the safety of Ellis' convictions, said it was time for police to "put up or shut up".

"All this innuendo is just sleaze tactics on the part of the police," she said.

"Isn't it about time they responded to the issues raised in A City Possessed instead of trying this underhand way of reviving the case?"

The book said that "moral panic" and parental hysteria led to Ellis being sentenced to 10 years imprisonment in 1993.

He was freed in February 2000 after serving two-thirds of his sentence.

Ellis called on Justice Minister Phil Goff in February to launch a new inquiry into his convictions after the New Zealand Law Journal highlighted flaws in the way his case had been handled.

Mr Goff said earlier that two appeal courts and a former Chief Justice had considered the convictions safe.