The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2003  Aug 16-31



Dominion Post
August 16, 2003

Creche case kids ask for legal aid
by Linley Boniface


Two teenagers who gave evidence in the Christchurch Civic Creche child abuse case have asked for legal funding to appear before the select committee looking into the controversy.

The teenagers, who break their 10-year silence to be interviewed exclusively in The Dominion Post today, said it was unfair that convicted paedophile Peter Ellis had the financial backing of wealthy supporters while they did not even have a lawyer to speak on their behalf.

Tom and Katrina - whose real names are suppressed - were a crucial part of the Crown case against Mr Ellis, who served seven years in prison for sexually abusing young children. Four of the convictions against him related to Katrina, and three related to Tom.

Since the publication of Lynley Hood's book, A City Possessed: The Christchurch Civic Creche Case, the campaign to pardon Mr Ellis has gathered force.

Earlier this month, publisher Barry Colman paid for a double-page advertisement in the Sunday Star-Times featuring transcripts of evidential interviews with Tom and Katrina, some of which were not played to the jury.

An 807-signature petition presented to Parliament's justice and electoral select committee calls for a royal commission of inquiry into the case.

Tom and Katrina want to give evidence before the select committee, but Tom's parents said they were initially told by the Justice Ministry that they would not be given funding. A ministry spokesperson now says the request is still being considered.

Tom's mother said she was pleased there was still a chance that the ministry would pay for a lawyer for Tom and Katrina.

"It's just a shame we couldn't have got legal representation the day those transcripts ended up in the paper," she said.

"No one can give us advice - not the Crown, not the police, not anyone. We don't have anyone to go to."

Roger McClay, the Commissioner for Children, said that if the ministry turned down the application, he might be able to give the teenagers some money from a fund set up to help the victims of child abuse.

"It is very brave of these young people to think about going before the select committee," he said.

"There are a lot of people who want to discredit them, which is why we hope the select committee will respect their wish to have their say. These teenagers have their lives to be getting on with."

He said he understood there were other young people who wanted to tell the select committee what had happened to them at Christchurch Civic Creche.

The select committee has asked the petitioners and the ministry to provide briefings by the end of this month.

It should consider the briefings early next month, and is then likely to seek comment from people involved in the case before making its recommendations to the Government.