The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2003  Aug 16-31



Otago Daily Times
August 20, 2003

Child victim says Ellis' backers wrong
NZPA

Christchurch: A child victim in the Christchurch Civic Creche sex abuse case is angry about criticism sparked by his first media interview.

Tom (not his real name) says Dunedin author Lynley Hood is "just so wrong" in her belief former creche worker Peter Ellis was an innocent man wrongly convicted.

Last Saturday, Tom and another complainant, Katrina (also a false name), reaffirmed the guilt of former creche worker Peter Ellis in national newspapers.

A decade ago, their evidence led to Ellis being convicted of 16 abuse charges, three relating to Tom and four to Katrina.

Now 17, the pair said that despite debate about the case, they still firmly believed they were abused by Ellis.

"I remember lots of it vividly," said Tom, who was nearly 3 when he began attending the creche.

"I stand by everything I said when I was little. I didn't make anything up."

Ms Hood, campaigning to overturn the Ellis convictions, said it was "scandalous" that child complainants felt compelled to speak out while the professionals involved in the case stayed silent.

"It's not the kids who should be fronting up and trying to defend what happened. It's the interviewers, the therapists, the police, and the prosecutors who should have known better. It's absolutely outrageous."

In A City Possessed, Ms Hood argues that memories of abuse the children might genuinely believe to be true had been induced by manipulative interviewing techniques.

Yesterday, Tom hit back.

"I am totally clear in remembering the abuse that the paedophile Peter Ellis did to me," he said in a statement.

"I wasn't manipulated; you just don't imagine that sort of stuff. How would Lynley Hood know what happened to me - she wasn't there. I was."

Tom's father said Ms Hood's comments were "a little bit below the belt".

"Our children find it upsetting when their integrity is called into question. They're now not afraid to speak up and say their piece and we support them in that."

Ms Hood is one of 140 high-profile New Zealanders to petition Parliament for a Royal Commission of Inquiry.

The justice and electoral select committee will next month begin weighing that call. -