The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports

2004



Newstalk ZB
September 7 2004

RNZ, TV3 and ZB told off by BSA

Radio New Zealand has been ordered to pay $5,300 dollars in legal costs to Peter Ellis, the man convicted over the Christchurch Civic creche abuse case.

Peter Ellis complained to the Broadcasting Standards Authority after Nine to Noon interviewed an anonymous mother and son who made unspecified allegations, which were not part of the court proceedings that led to his conviction.

The BSA has ruled the broadcast seriously breached standards of fairness.


It has also ordered Nine to Noon to broadcast an apology, publish a summary of the decision in the metropolitan dailies and pay the maximum of $5,000 in costs to the Crown.

Meanwhile, comments made by TV and radio broadcaster Paul Holmes have also been under discussion at the BSA.

He has been told it is acceptable to call an MP a 'confused bag of lard', but not to describe women attending rugby league parties as 'moles'.

The Newstalk ZB host used the term 'bag of lard' to describe Tariana Turia.

The BSA has ruled, while the remarks were personally abusive and unfair to Mrs Turia, that does not necessarily mean they are beyond the bounds of good taste or decency.

However the Authority says his use of the word 'mole' to describe women attending league parties perpetuates the myth that women who are sexually assaulted somehow ask for it.

It has ordered The Radio Network to broadcast an approved summary of its decision.

TV3 has also received a slap on the wrist from the BSA over the so-called guinea pig letter.

The Broadcasting Standards Authority has upheld a complaint by a viewer after an interview with the lawyer of a young Sri Lankan girl deported earlier this year.

The letter eventually led to the resignation of Immigration Minister Lianne Dalziel.

The BSA ruled the interview was unbalanced as it did not give the lawyer the opportunity to respond to the Minister's criticism, and that the item was also unfair and misleading.

The Authority has ordered TV 3 to broadcast a summary and explanation of its decision.