The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Main Index


2005 Index 2 (Apr-July)

 




The Press
April 4 2005

Ellis inquiry delay 'helped cause heart attack'
by Matt Conway

Stress over a bid to quash child-abuse convictions is likely to have contributed to Peter Ellis's heart attack, his mother says.

But Christchurch Central MP Tim Barnett, who heads the select committee looking into the Civic Creche case, has defended the 21 months so far taken to weigh the call for an inquiry.

Chest pain and sweats struck Ellis, 47, while he was reading at home in North Canterbury on Thursday night.

Ash-grey and requiring oxygen, he was rushed by ambulance to Christchurch Hospital. Last night he remained seriously ill in the coronary care unit.

Lesley Ellis was startled when her son knocked on her bedroom door and said, "Mum, I'm having a heart attack."

She rang a neighbour, who urged her to call 111. Two ambulances and a duty doctor attended.

Peter Ellis "flopped back on his bed and didn't move" as he waited for help.

"I was a bit too gobsmacked to know what was going on," Lesley Ellis said.

It had been a draining week for Peter Ellis, with the loss of two staunch supporters, relatives Gordon and Mollie Seatter. The couple died naturally within a few days of each other.

He had attended their combined funeral service on Thursday.

Lesley Ellis believes politicians added to her son's already serious health problems by drawing out the decision on a commission of inquiry.

Since November 2003, when Peter Ellis was hospitalised with a serious infection that stemmed from having a tooth out, his immune system has been depleted.

Doctors have struggled to combat the problem, placing him on what his mother described as a bucketload of pills.

"They have not got him right. He sleeps most afternoons for a couple of hours and he is often uncomfortable and achy," Lesley Ellis said. Delays over the fight to clear his name have added to the stress, she said.

A petition calling for a top-level look at the creche case has been with the Justice and Electoral Select Committee for 21 months.

Chaired by Barnett, the committee is inching towards making its recommendation to the Government.

Lesley Ellis said that in her view the petition's slow crawl through Parliament had helped cause her son's first heart attack.

"You wait all this time and try and get something out of Tim Barnett and he's just skirting round, skirting round and doesn't do anything," she said. "I feel as if I'm looking over my shoulder for what's going to happen next."

Barnett said yesterday he understood the Ellis family's frustration, but a report on the petition had required considerably more work than usual.

"We're very aware of the fact people are critical of the time we're taking," he said. "We want a good, quality report and if it takes time, it takes time."

Other select committee priorities had contributed to the delay, Barnett added.

The creche report would be finished before the election, hopefully by the end of July.

Cardiac problems feature in Peter Ellis's family. Both his grandfathers died of heart attacks in their 40s.

In 1993 the creche staffer was found guilty of abusing seven children in his care (one complainant later said she had lied, and the relevant convictions were quashed).

Ellis served two-thirds of a 10-year jail sentence