The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Main Index


2005 Index 2 (Apr-July)

 



Otago Daily Times
April 20 2005

Barrister silent on career change
By Dene Mackenzie, Political Editor

Judith Ablett Kerr
Otago Daily Times
April 20 2005
            Judith Ablett-Kerr


High profile Dunedin barrister Judith Ablett-Kerr QC may be considering a career change to a National Party MP by securing a top place on the party list.

Mrs Ablett-Kerr, speaking from Wellington yesterday, said she was in no position to comment on the speculation she might become a National Party list-only candidate.

Her selection could push current Dunedin-based list MP Katherine Rich down to a position where there would be little likelihood of her being re-elected from the list, adding further insult to the supporters of Mrs Rich who are angered by her demotion from four to 10 in caucus ranking.

National is refusing to confirm or deny the speculation that Mrs Ablett-Kerr will secure one of the party’s five list-only places, with a spokesman for leader Dr Don Brash saying the party was not going to “pre-announce its list”.

Dunedin’s highest ranking party official, Southern region deputy chairman Craig Myles, said he had had no dealings with Mrs Ablett-Kerr at a party level.

Dunedin North chairman Andy Rich, Mrs Rich’s husband, said the speculation about the lawyer’s candidacy was “news to me”.

Mrs Rich refused to comment except to say there were many good people in Dunedin who would do a good job in Parliament.

“It’s not my role to comment in relation to the selection of list MPs,” she said.

However, party sources encouraged the ODT to continue its inquiries as they were confident that behind-the-scenes talks were being held or had been held between party officials and Mrs Ablett-Kerr.

Any link between National and Mrs Ablett-Kerr is tenuous at best.

The closest this newspaper could find was that Dr Brash and Mrs Rich presented to Parliament a petition calling for a royal commission of inquiry into the Christchurch Civic Creche Case at the same time Mrs Ablett-Kerr was seeking special leave from the Privy Council in London to proceed with an appeal for Peter Ellis, the convicted creche child molester.

Mrs Ablett-Kerr also debated with Dr Brash on law and order at a public forum in Dunedin last year, questioning him on the wisdom of National’s tough stance.

Possible issues that could be against the selection of Mrs Ablett-Kerr as a list-only candidate for National include. —

·           She is a white woman from the South when already there is Mrs Rich, and new candidates Jaquie Dean, in Otago, and Jo Goodhew, in Aoraki.

·           National is vulnerable in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch and needs high-profile candidates in those cities.

·           National already has six lawyers in its 27-person caucus.

·           Mrs Ablett-Kerr will be seen as soft on law and order because of the high-profile appeal cases in which she becomes involved, when National is pressing for a hard-line on crime.


Aspects in favour of Mrs Ablett-Kerr being selected include . —

·           A national profile because of her formidable reputation in court.

·           A top debater because of her court experience.

·           Her ability to deal with complex legal legislation.

·           Dr Brash needs more women to counter his demotion of Mrs Rich and former Maori affairs spokeswoman Georgina Te Heu Heu.


National Party president Judy Kirk said the media would be informed once the party had confirmed its list on May 28. “I’m not going to announce any names before then. It’s inappropriate for me to do that.” There had been much interest in the party’s list and it would be fielding some “very good candidates”. The board had the right to nominate up to five list-only placings and had already confirmed Dr Brash would get one of those, she said