The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Home


2007 Index

 




The Press
June 16 2007

Press Council has disgraced itself over complaint
Letter to the Editor
by Ross Francis, Masterton

The Press Council has disgraced itself with its handling of the complaint of Freda Briggs (June 13).

The council refers to letters written by me and suggests that my comments were inaccurate and possibly malicious. It did not seek comment from me before reaching its decision.

Your readers were entitled to know that I dispute that Ms Briggs has published more than a few papers in peer-reviewed journals.

Also, that I believe that whatever expertise she possesses, it does not extend to the interviewing of child sexual abuse victims, and that Ms Briggs has, despite her claims to the contrary, recently endorsed the myth that is ritual abuse. Teachers, according to Ms Briggs, should observe changes in children’s behaviour and watch for signs of abuse. This advice, which may have been fashionable 20 years ago, is dangerous and should be ignored.

There are no behaviours specific to child sexual abuse victims. That is why forensic interviews are important - they are the most reliable, and often the only, source of information about a child's abuse status.

Well trained professionals should perform such interviews, not counsellors or child advocates.

If an expert comments on a controversial issue, the public has a right to expect that he or she is credible.

Freda Briggs should take no comfort from the Press Council’s bizarre decision.