Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse of Prisoners by Police - Main Index


News Reports - 2

 



Newstalk ZB
March 3 2005

Top cop slams whistleblowers

South Auckland's police chief is labelling officers who go public over problems in the force as "traitors".

Counties Manukau Police District Commander Steve Shortland has responded to evidence from the trial of Senior Sergeant Anthony Solomona, who has been found guilty of assaulting a 17-year old suspect at a petrol station.

He says evidence of police forcing suspects to write apology letters and a photo of a masked policeman carrying an axe and a machete is disturbing.

However, in a leaked memo, he voices his disappointment over colleagues who run to the media and let their workmates down by revealing practices they are concerned about.

He describes the perpetrators as "traitors", and suggests they are doing it for money, for sex or because they are just stupid.

The memo also urges police to dob in colleagues who are speaking to the media.

New Zealand First MP Ron Mark has slammed the memo, saying he is appalled.

He says police bosses are clearly on a witch-hunt, seeking to shut down and bully into silence officers who are facing problems because of poor resourcing.

He says Superintendent Shortland's comments are tantamount to bullying. Mr Mark says police need to be able to speak out with their concerns.

In one case last month, Newstalk ZB revealed a police officer had written to the Police News magazine claiming that officers were recording crime inaccurately on instructions from their supervisors, in an effort to make the crime statistics look better.

The letter, signed "Doubting Thomas", says "I thought of all the crimes that get reported where a file number is given and the matter is never investigated... These uninvestigated crimes must account for around half of all reported crime".

The latest crime statistics, released yesterday, showed an 8.2 percent decrease in crime in 2004 and that the resolution rate was up 1.1 percent to 44.6 percent of all offences, a rate which is the envy of other Western police forces according to Commissioner Rob Robinson.