Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Abuse by Police - Main Index


News Reports - 5

 




NZ Herald
March 11 2005

Ex-judge to quiz police in 'sick culture' inquiry


  Sir David Tompkins

An inquiry set up to examine South Auckland police practices will not question the officer who sparked the investigation, but other policemen are likely to get a grilling.

Former High Court Judge Sir David Tompkins was yesterday appointed to head the inquiry, which will examine allegations of a "sick" culture within South Auckland ranks.

The allegations emerged during the trial of Wiri-based Senior-Sergeant Anthony Solomona.

Solomona was found guilty this month of assaulting a 17-year-old Manukau man in February last year.

During the six-day hearing, the court heard details of a number of police practices, which included the humiliation of young suspects forced into being photographed wearing demeaning signs.

The court was also shown a picture of a machete and axe-wielding policeman posing with a number of other weapons and a sign saying "RIP to Section 4" (the emergency response unit headed by Solomona).

District Court Judge Bruce Davidson blasted South Auckland police while giving his verdict on Solomona, saying the evidence heard in court hinted at a sick police culture.

Announcing Justice Tompkins' appointment, Police Commissioner Rob Robinson said the inquiry's terms of reference would be "to determine whether there is evidence of a police culture that condones or encourages acts of violence or other inappropriate treatment towards prisoners, suspects or other persons in the Counties-Manukau Police District".

Justice Tompkins is at present out of the country, but his assistant, Inspector Pieter Roozendaal of North Shore-Waitakere, said Solomona, who has been suspended and is awaiting sentencing, would not be called by the inquiry, but his colleague, Sergeant John Nelson, probably would.

Mr Nelson claimed during Solomona's trial to have seen, more than once, the photographing of young suspects. He claimed it was done as a joke, but was something only police officers would find amusing.

"It would be fair to say we would be wanting to speak to Sergeant Nelson," Mr Roozendaal said.

The inquiry will be run from North Shore-Waitakere headquarters, to keep "as much distance as we can" from Counties-Manukau, he said.

It will not pursue any criminal offending that might emerge from the investigation. That will be left to the Police Complaints Authority.

The inquiry's findings will go to Mr Robinson.

 

The man in charge

 

·           Justice Tompkins, 76, is a former partner in Tompkins & Wake of Hamilton and was appointed a Queen's Counsel in 1974.

·           He was appointed to the High Court in 1983, and has served on the Court of Appeal, the Privy Council and the Court of Appeal of Tonga.

·           He was made a Knight Commander of the New Zealand Order of Merit in 1999.