Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Psychiatric Hospitals Index


Jan-June 2004 Index

 



The Manawatu Standard
March 23 2004

Lake Alice decision delay upsets victims
by Lee Matthews

A preliminary decision about laying charges against former Lake Alice Hospital staff who allegedly abused and tortured children in the 1970s is expected next month.

The Crown Law Office is expected to give the Police Commissioner's Office its advice within weeks. Then Commissioner Robert Robinson will decide whether to lay charges.

"A final decision is still some time away," said Police Commissioner's Office spokesman Michael Player. "The complexity and the age of the issue makes it complicated."

Meanwhile, former Lake Alice Hospital residents are chafing at how long it is taking.

Sharyn Collis, who lives in Palmerston North and who was raped, given paraldehyde injections and electroconvulsive therapy without anaesthetic as punishments while at Lake Alice, says she started trying to get information about whether charges would be laid straight after her 2001 apology and compensation payment from the Government.

"I have rung, I have emailed, I have given them my files, I have offered to assist in any way possible," she said. "And I just keep getting fobbed off. Nothing happens, except I get `we have received your letter and we will keep in touch with you' letters.

"The apology and the compensation proves that the Government believed and accepted our evidence. Why is this taking so long?

"I think it's just too hard for them. I think they're hoping it will go away."

Massey University clinical psychologist Jan Dickson is another person who says the delays are "disgraceful".