Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Psychiatric Hospitals Index


Jan-June 2004 Index

 



One News
May 31 2004

Crown probes alleged patient abuse

The Attorney General says the Crown is currently investigating 62 allegations of past abuse of patients at psychiatric hospitals.

Margaret Wilson issued a statement on Monday afternoon in response to claims by former patients on the Sunday programme that they were physically abused by staff at Porirua Hospital in the 1960s and 1970s.

A former nurse accused of abusing mental health patients as young as eight in Porirua Hospital is denying any knowledge of violence or abuse at the institution.

The anti-violence campaigner Jim Moriarty is threatening legal action over allegations of abuse by former patients on TVNZ's Sunday programme.

Moriarty, who was a trainee nurse at the time, says he has no recollection of hitting an eight-year-old with a wet towel or beating another boy unconscious. He says the second patient admits to having hallucinations around the same time.

Moriarty says the former patients are trying to make money.

The Sunday investigation revealed that children as young as eight were placed in a psychiatric institution because no one close to them knew how to control their behaviour.

Many of the children were from broken homes and in the care of child welfare and many ended up in Porirua Hospital - New Zealand's largest psychiatric institution in the 1960s and 70s.

Now those children are adults and they say they are emotionally scarred by their childhood experiences.

They told Sunday they never suffered from mental illness as children and were simply victims of circumstance and the social and health systems of the day.

A group of them have begun a class action against the government - seeking an inquiry and compensation.

And in statements of claim before the High Court they name former staff of the hospital who they say physically and mentally abused them when they were at their most vulnerable.

Wilson says legal claims being looked at include some from Porirua Hospital and she says she expects another 44 claims to be filed.

A lawyer representing 79 former patients who claim they were abused at Porirua Hospital says the volume of claims should force a government inquiry.

Sonja Cooper has called for an inquiry to be set up into the alleged abuses and for compensation to be paid - as was done for patients of Lake Alice Psychiatric Hospital.

Cooper says more than 100 former mental health patients claim they were physically and sexually abused at the hospital during the 1960s and 70s. She says 53 claims have been filed with the High Court, and there will be at least twice that.

Cooper says the government should fund a full inquiry.

Wilson says no decision will be made on that until the Crown has completed its investigation.