Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Psychiatric Hospitals Index


Jan-June 2004 Index

 



The Press
June 23 2004

Desperate days at Sunnyside recalled
By Kamala Hayman


Sally (not her real name) knew she was not like other girls. Withdrawn and depressed, she was secretly scrubbing her stomach with sandpaper.

Sometimes she would grab a piece of broken glass, a razor blade – anything sharp – and slice into her arms and legs.

She had started self-harming when she was 12 years old. She did not know why except that she felt driven to it when feelings of misery overwhelmed her.

Sally's mother had a drinking problem and paid her little attention. She lived in great fear of her "mean, miserly" father until he died of cancer when she was 13.

It was Sally's school that finally noticed she was having problems and suggested she see a hospital psychiatrist.

Sally was secretly pleased.

Aged 16, she hoped the doctor would help her become like the other girls. "I thought `I'm going to be normal, I will go to dances and do all the things the other girls do'."

But it was not to be. Sally would never be a normal teenager.

Her first psychiatrist found her unco-operative – Sally had resisted his attempts to check her breasts – and announced she must be admitted to hospital.

She was about to embark on 14 years in the hands of psychiatrists and psychologists who used increasingly extreme and bizarre attempts to cure her "madness".

Not one would ask why she was so desperately unhappy. "They told me I was mad, and I believed them," said Sally. "Though in my heart I always knew I had nothing wrong with me."

Initially she was in and out of both Timaru Hospital and Princess Margaret in Christchurch, where she was drugged, subjected to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), and even put to sleep for days and nights on end in the apparent hope that she would awake, cured.

Little progress was made and in 1975 she was committed to Stewart Villa in Sunnyside. "I spent three years in a secure unit where murderers, rapists, arsonists, and retards became my family."

Her diaries record 74 treatments of ECT. She has little memory of them but is convinced she still suffers the after-effects; absent episodes, epileptic-type seizures and short-term memory loss.

The ward was filled with violence. One patient narrowly missed her throat with a fork; a doctor was put in hospital after being stabbed by another.

One male nurse would push her against the wall and forcefully kiss her. Another staff member physically hurled her down the corridor for misbehaving.

One Christmas, she won a basket of goodies in a raffle which bewilderingly including sewing needles and razor blades. Her room-mate, a 14-year-old girl from Kingslea, took the blades and cut herself badly.

Sally was blamed and ordered to clean up the blood.

In front of other patients in the communal day room Sally's psychiatrist railed against her, accusing Sally of being "bad" and "menacing" and causing her room-mate great damage.

Deeply hurt and humiliated, Sally retreated to her room and cut herself, seriously. She ended up in Burwood Hospital.

Back at Sunnyside, this same psychiatrist offered Sally the choice of a lobotomy or an extended stint in solitary confinement.

The latter was intended to force Sally to "regress" to a neonatal stage so that her supposedly disordered personality could be rebuilt. The room had nothing but a mattress on the floor and a potty. The window was too high to see out of and Sally was not allowed anything to read, listen to, or write with.

"I went downhill very badly. I screamed and banged the walls, I was in total despair.

"It was like I was being punished over and over again, for being a dirty little girl. That was what my mother called me."

At one point Sally was brought out for a meeting and noticed the ward door open. "I ran for it. I was heading for Annex Road to jump under the nearest truck but they caught me.

"It was the most helpless feeling, there was nobody there to help that you could tell anything to. My family never kept in touch. The State owned you and doctors and nurses could do anything."

If the doctors discovered she had cut herself she would be given ECT. Her cuts would be stitched without anaesthetic.

She remembers her terror the day she was given ECT without being anaesthetised. She was given a muscle relaxant needed to prevent spasms so violent they could throw a patient off the bed. "It felt like I had concrete poured inside me, it was the worst experience. I passed out."

On another occasion she was denied medical treatment for a chronic physical condition. A sympathetic nurse sneaked her out to a GP. He was shocked by her condition and prescribed medication but back at Sunnyside this had to be kept hidden.

Sally was variously diagnosed as schizophrenic, paranoid, manic depressive and an hysterical neurotic. They were all wrong. A number of supportive staff were convinced she did not have a mental illness and would sneak her to their homes for visits. She was encouraged by them to get out.

When her psychiatrist was on sick leave – having been stabbed by a patient – Sally asked for a trial release and it was agreed. In 1978 Sally was released from Sunnyside and vowed she would never return.

She immediately stopped all her psychiatric medication. Determined to rebuild her life, she lied about her past to land a job and her own flat.

She had to teach herself how to cook and to look after herself. After all, for years she had had to ask permission to have a shower, even to go to the toilet.

Sally eventually fell in love, married and had two children. Tragically her daughter died in her cot at just four months.

After 13 years her marriage broke up.

It was to prove a turning point in her life. Broken-hearted at losing the first person she believed had ever loved her, Sally slid back into a deep depression. But she recognised the signs and having a young child to care for, knew she needed help.

She remembered a sympathetic psychologist from Sunnyside and discovered he now worked in the community. He was the first professional Sally was to talk to about the horrific details of her childhood.

As a six-year-old Sally had been raped by a neighbour. He was the brother of a high-profile member of her community who threatened to kill her if she breathed a word about the abuse. The abuse continued for another four years.

Sally has since discovered her mother knew of the abuse but feared the shame it would bring on the family if it became public.

Failed by her parents, Sally believes she was easy prey for abusers. "They could see that no-one cared about me."

At 11, on a horse riding trip at a friend's farm, four teenage boys held her down and raped her. Her friend watched, doing nothing to come to her aid.

"That was when I went really mad. I used to sit at school and think I was going to have four babies.

"I became really withdrawn. That was when I started to sandpaper my skin off, I felt dirty."

Though Sally had never forgotten the sexual abuse, she had never associated it with her teenage depression and self-harm.

And nor had any of the countless medical professionals who cared for her as a teenager and young adult. The connection was first made in her counselling sessions following her marriage break-up.

Now aged 56, Sally's warm brown eyes and easy smile reveal nothing of her past.

She is one of about 200 people wanting an inquiry into the psychiatric hospitals of New Zealand in the 1960s and 70s.

She does not seek financial compensation, nor even an apology. "I just want the world to know about the injustices and hope it doesn't happen again."

Tim Beswick, 39, grew up in Ilam where he was sexually abused by a neighbour.

He developed behavioural difficulties and was sent to the now notorious Marylands school, run by St John of God. He suffered further repeated sexual abuse and rape and last year was awarded $148,000 by the Catholic order.

At 13, diagnosed as having a mild intellectual disability, Tim was sent to Templeton Hospital where he said he was again sexually abused.

He became something of a child arsonist, repeatedly lighting small fires. "I was an angry, angry little boy."

In 1980 he was sent to Sunnyside where he was heavily medicated, given ECT, and kept in solitary for days on end.

When he was "a good boy" he was rewarded with cigarettes and has not been able to kick his nicotine habit to this day.

Now living in his own house in Leeston, Beswick said he still found it difficult to trust people.

He had made countless attempts to take his own life and nightmares often woke him in the night. "I'm a mess at the end of the day.

"I never had the experience other young people had. They took my life away, my manhood, my reading and writing away, my family away."

He said he wanted the truth of what happened to him and others to be told.