Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(1) Oct 3-5 2004 Index

 



NZ Herald
October 5 2004

Government orders abuse probe
by Ainsley Thomson

Defence Minister Mark Burton has ordered an urgent inquiry into allegations that Army cadets were physically, sexually and psychologically abused at a Waiouru cadet school.

Former cadet Ian Fraser's report, posted on the internet, which detailed abuse of cadets as young as 15 at the school during the 1960s, 70s and 80s, yesterday prompted other cadets to reveal more allegations of abuse.

Some said those responsible should face criminal charges.

The report detailed the 1981 fatal shooting of 17-year-old cadet Grant Bain, for which Corporal Andrew William Read was charged with causing death by carelessly misusing a firearm.

Yesterday, the policeman who handled the case, retired Detective Sergeant Piers Hunt, told the Herald Read should have been charged with manslaughter.

But Mr Hunt said his superiors would not allow the more serious charge.

Auckland man Eric West, who attended the school in 1964 when he was 15, told the Herald about a beating at Waiouru which left him hospitalised for a week with a displaced coccyx (tailbone) and led to a complete mental breakdown.

It was the first time he had told anyone, including his wife, about the incidents.

"You feel ashamed of yourself. To a degree it's almost like being raped, because you think somehow it was your fault, when of course it wasn't," he said.

Late yesterday, Mr Burton took the unusual step of requesting the office of the Chief of the Defence Force to conduct a preliminary investigation into the allegations.

"The issues that Mr Fraser has outlined are serious and they deserve to be looked into seriously," he said.

Mr Burton urged other people with knowledge of abuse at the school to contact his office or the Chief of the Defence Force's office.

Mr Fraser, who attended the school in 1971, said he was pleased the truth was finally coming out about the school, attended by 5000 cadets between 1948 and 1991.

"They are compensating prisoners for the hard time they had in prison. We were serving our country at the time and this is what they did to us."

For the past six months Mr Fraser, who lives in Perth, has researched alleged abuse at the school.

Besides the fatal shooting of Grant Bain, he found reports of cadets being sodomised, or sexually assaulted with broom handles, leading to more than one suicide.

Mr Fraser said that while he was at the school all wardrobe doors were removed in the barracks because cadets were often left inside them "bleeding, unconscious and unattended to".

He spoke of a climate of fear, the constant threat of violence and neglect by the Army.

Mr West, now an account manager at a telecommunications company, said he was psychologically and physically terrorised for six months, until he had a mental breakdown and was discharged from the Army.

On one occasion he was charged with conduct prejudicial to military discipline.

"My alleged offence was to have wax in one ear. So I was a 'dirty little boy'. I was placed on restrictions [confined to the barracks] and I was also ordered by the commanding officer to be scrubbed.

"That evening, about 10 cadets grabbed me, took me into the showers, stripped me naked and threw me into a cold shower. They then scrubbed me with the kind of brush you use to scrub concrete."

Mr West believes the men responsible should be prosecuted.

"For some of the things that were done and some of the things that were encouraged, these guys should go to jail.

"At the time I thought they were making men out of us, but I wonder what kind of men they made."

- additional reporting, Nicola Boyes