Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(5) Oct 10-16 2004 Index

 



NZ Herald
October 12 2004

Independent assessor to probe abuse claims
by Kevin Taylor

An independent assessor will be appointed to examine claims of abuse at Waiouru's Army cadet school and Defence Minister Mark Burton indicated an official commission of inquiry was possible.

Mr Burton yesterday announced some details of the Government's response to the abuse claims and revealed his office had received 85 calls so far alleging abuse.

The issue erupted last week after former cadet Ian Fraser, now living in Perth, alleged widespread "physical, psychological and sexual abuse" of cadets from the 1960s until the school closed in 1991. It had opened in 1948.

Mr Burton told the post-Cabinet meeting press conference an independent assessor would be appointed to investigate all claims in a "neutral manner" and he hoped to put a name to next Monday's Cabinet for approval.

Defence Force policies to deal with such incidents would also be reviewed.

Asked if the inquiry would be conducted under commissions of inquiry rules, he said that would be decided next Monday.

"I will take to Cabinet the options and recommendations as to the terms of reference."

He said the assessor should be someone of high standing, with a significant legal background, and "seen to be independent of the military".

Mr Fraser welcomed the Government's move, but wanted to know who the assessor was and what the terms of reference would be before offering a firm opinion.

He said having watched commissions of inquiry into police corruption in New South Wales and Western Australia, it was important the inquiry head had the power to compel testimony.

The assessor would look at information held by the Defence Force and other parties, including Mr Fraser.

Mr Burton said the assessor would report to him and he would consult with the Attorney-General before reporting to Cabinet. Any criminal offending that emerged would be referred to the police.

He did not know how long the inquiry would take. Mr Fraser has compiled a dossier of about 300 complaints.

Asked to comment on people seeking to downplay the abuse, Mr Burton said he and the Government had no tolerance for acts of violence and brutality that were "no more acceptable then than now".

Meanwhile, senior criminal lawyer and president of the Howard League for Penal Reform, Peter Williams, QC, warned against being too hasty with prosecutions.

He said there was an "extremely arbitrary" statute of limitations on prosecuting crimes, particularly more serious cases.

"You can be too heavy-handed and it's not always conducive to the interests of justice generally," Mr Williams said.