Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


Waiouru (NZ Army) - Index


(5) Oct 10-16 2004 Index

 



Manawatu Standard
October 14 2004

Cover-up easy in Army camp
by David Eames

The former officer, who served at Waiouru in the 1970s, says conditions were not much different to those in high schools and boarding schools of the era. Corporal punishment was enforced in the education system, and this could have contributed to the cadets' mindset, he said.

Claims of abuse in the military surface regularly and are not unique to New Zealand, he said, citing Britain's Sandhurst Military Academy.

"Every military college in the world has had these scandals in their lifetime."

He said there was always "a level of boisterousness" among the cadets, but the "closed nature" of the Waiouru school meant abuses could be "covered up easily".

The former officer did not want to be named or give details of his occupation as it is possible he will have to give evidence at a future inquiry.

Though he believes it likely

the abuses did actually take place, the man was quick to assert the behaviour would not have been condoned by military officials in any way.

Any commission set up to investigate the abuses would have to be careful to judge the cadet training school with like establishments, he says.

"(The) commission will have to tease out what was the prevailing culture in equivalent training institutes at the time."

It would also have to be careful not to be inundated with claims, many of a dubious nature.

"At the very least it will come up with lots of individual cases, a long time ago, (where) memory has been very selective."

A commission would doubtless dredge up a lot of information, much of it "very disturbing to know", he says, but it would have to be careful of stories embellished in the hope of receiving compensation payments.

"You are going to get a lot of information coming forward and it will depend on the reputation and skill and the standing of the people who do the inquiry."

He did not, however, support the idea of financial compensation, preferring that counselling and other support services be offered.

"If people have been genuinely affected by the experience, we should be offering all the support and whatever we need to do to help . . ."