Moral Panics in New Zealand

Fear of pervert Drivers

Peterellis.org.nz

Moral Panics Index

Banning Drivers, Index


Banning drivers with convictions
Reports 3 (14-31 Jan 2006)




The Timaru Herald
January 14 2006

Govt seeking remedy for driving law

Government lawyers are searching for a legal loophole in a new law which stops bus drivers with minor historic criminal convictions from getting behind the wheel.

The Land Transport Amendment Act, which takes effect on Monday, specifies a series of serious offences, led by murder and sexual crimes, that have no recourse to appeals against licence removal.

Hundreds of drivers have received letters saying their passenger endorsement licences will be suspended.

This has caught out some drivers who have minor historic sex convictions.

Transport Safety Minister Harry Duynhoven yesterday said he was awaiting a legal team's review of the new transport act.

The report from the Crown Law Office was due yesterday. It may point to a wider appeal process for those that feel they have been unjustly treated.

"It's possible and one of the things I've asked for is advice from Crown Law ... what the chances are for having a way through for those that society will consider to be good and desirable people," Duynhoven said.

"I've asked them to look at the issue and tell me what the ramifications are and is there a way of fixing this that doesn't require (further) legislation, because that's a slow process."

Duynhoven noted 38,000 plus P (passenger) endorsements had been reviewed, with about 200 of those receiving letters saying "it may be that your ability to continue to hold a P endorsement is extinguished on (Monday), you should seek legal advice".

Duynhoven said there was about eight to 10 drivers convicted years ago for crimes including unlawful carnal knowledge with a woman just shy of her 16th birthday, while the men were themselves youngsters.

"I'm not for a moment saying they're not worthy citizens," he said.

"What I am saying is Parliament unanimously voted for legislation which said these people with specific sexual offences and specific violence offences should not be continuing to hold a passenger endorsement."

If there were a way forward he would push to revisit the legislation when Parliament returned after Waitangi Day.

Kaiapoi bus driver Beau Harrison, 62, employed by Hawarden Garage and Transport, has been caught by the new act.

He had all but forgotten about his involvement nearly 40 years ago with a young woman when they both worked in a shearing gang.

He did not realise she was under 16, and was fined for unlawful carnal knowledge.

He joins a Dunedin bus driver whose licence is being suspended because as a 16-year-old, 34 years ago, he slept with his girlfriend two days short of her 16th birthday.

The Amalgamated Workers Union has condemned the legislation as extreme.

Union secretary Calvin Fisher said the act was heavy handed and unjust.