Moral Panics in New Zealand

Fear of pervert Drivers

Peterellis.org.nz

Moral Panics Index

Banning Drivers, Index


Banning drivers with convictions
Reports 3 (14-31 Jan 2006)




Sunday Star Times
January 15 2006

New transport law will 'destroy my life', taxi driver says
by Jennifer Dann

When Queenstown bus driver Garry Adams was 16 he went to Dunedin's St Kilda beach one night to "fool around" with a 15-year-old girl.

No clothes were removed in the consensual activity, which he described as heavy petting. But after the girl was late home, her parents complained to police and he was charged with indecent assault.

"The police told me if I pleaded guilty, there would be a $55 fine and it would go away. Thirty-five years later it's coming back to haunt me. This is going to destroy my life," he said.

Adams is one of 209 bus and taxi drivers who will lose their licences tomorrow when new laws preventing people with certain convictions from holding a passenger transport licence come into force. Land Transport New Zealand figures show a third of their crimes are more than 30 years old - 85% are over 10 years old.

Convicted murderers and people with sex convictions are unable to appeal against the ban. Of those affected by the changes, two are murderers and more than 100 have sex-related convictions.

However, 47 drivers can apply to have their licences reinstated because their convictions appear in a list of crimes specified in the legislation which includes attempted murder, contract killing, kidnapping, robbery, grievous bodily harm, infecting with disease and throwing acid.

Transport Safety Minister Harry Duynhoven has promised to revisit the legislation when parliament reconvenes on February 7.

Adams said he and other victims of the legislation wanted the right to earn a living while it was sorted out.

His wife Donna and employer Real Journeys were standing by him. He was on paid stress leave while the company lobbied the government to reinstate his licence.

Bus and Coach Association deputy executive director Dave Smith said he had been inundated with calls and emails from anguished small business operators who would struggle to stay afloat after losing key staff due to the law changes.

Residents of Reefton are likely to be left without a taxi service as a result of the new laws. Kevin Arnesen and his wife operate the West Coast town's only taxi and shuttle service, but will be forced to close down after his licence expires tomorrow because of a 40-year-old conviction.

The 53-year-old was 13 when he was convicted of rape and sent to a boys home after touching a five- year-old girl's genitals. "It was just kids experimenting. I never tried to force myself on her," he said.

Arnesen said he also had convictions for burglary and falling asleep while driving, but had kept his nose clean for the last decade. The couple could not afford to pay a replacement driver.

Questions have also been raised about inequities in the way the law may be applied.

A damning Audit Office report last year on taxi industry checks blasted a lack of co-operation between cab licensing agency Land Transport New Zealand, the police and the Immigration Service.

It said little had changed since a similar report in 1997, but since deregulation, taxi driver numbers had risen from 2567 in 1989 to 23,000 in 2004.

Land Transport spokesman Andy Knackstedt said it was difficult to carry out background checks on immigrants from corrupt countries. Records were often incomplete or non-existent from countries like Somalia, where civil society has all but broken down.

He said Land Transport was looking at ways to tighten screening. One solution discussed was requiring applicants to have resided in New Zealand for five years with a clean record.