Moral Panics

Fear of perverts teaching

 

peterellis.org.nz

 

Moral Panics Index

 

Teachers Index


        
2006 Index




The Dominion Post
September 26 2006

Males victims of childcare 'sexism'
by Lane Nichols

Grandfather figure: Elyse Davey, 2, with David Butler, supervisor at Kea House creche. He is the only male employee there. An industry body said children are being 'quarantined' from men.
Photo by Kent Blechynden, Dominion Post



Children are being "quarantined" from men by sexist recruitment policies in the early childhood sector, an industry body says.

The policies are linked to "paedophile hysteria" of the 1990s, it believes.

The claims follow revelations that men account for less than 1 per cent of New Zealand's preschool teachers – a figure tipped to drop further in a new report.

Some say they are too scared to cuddle a child or change a nappy.

Early Childhood Council chief executive Sue Thorne said children were missing crucial contact with male role models because men felt unwelcome in the profession.

The problem was linked to the "paedophile hysteria" that followed Christchurch's Civic Creche abuse scandal involving Peter Ellis in the 1990s.

It was now too dangerous for male teachers to cuddle a distressed child or change a nappy because of the culture – and some parents refused to send children to centres that employed men.

Mrs Thorne called on the Government, teacher unions and education providers to launch a recruitment drive aimed at men to tackle a severe skills shortage and bring the male-female teacher ratio into line with other countries in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.

"We have created a society in which we have quarantined our children from our men. (Male teachers) feel they will be treated as suspect till proven innocent."

A report issued yesterday by the Childforum research network says sexism is rife in the early childcare sector.

Of its 13,741 employees last year, just 132 were men, researcher Sarah Farquhar said.

"The child abuse argument has proven to be a convenient excuse to keep men out of an occupation that has been a site for feminist activism since the 1970s."

There was no evidence that male teachers were more likely to abuse children, she said.

David Butler has been an early childhood teacher for more than 30 years. He is now a supervisor at Kelburn's Kea House creche – and is its only male employee.

He felt discriminated against trying to find work in the 1990s but was now trusted by parents and colleagues, he said.

Mr Butler said he knew male teachers who refused to change nappies or cuddle children but he continued doing so.

"I'm 56 and a grandfather. If you've got policies to protect you and your practices are good, you're not at risk."

Education Minister Steve Maharey said professional qualifications and better wages had made the sector more attractive to men.

He planned a recruitment drive to try to get more male teachers.