Moral Panics

Fear of perverts teaching

 

peterellis.org.nz

 

Moral Panics Index

 

Teachers Index


        
2006 Index




The Press
September 26 2006

Men needed for childcare
by Arwen Hann

Paranoia surrounding child sex abuse is masking some of the real barriers to recruiting men into childcare, experts say.

The Early Childhood Council has called for a government-led initiative to encourage more males into the sector, saying the "paedophile hysteria of the 1990s" had led to men leaving the profession and put off potential new recruits.

"Many men don't feel welcome in childcare," chief executive Sue Thorne said. "They feel they will be treated as suspect until proven innocent."

The call follows research by Sarah Farquhar that revealed less than 1 per cent of today's early-childhood teachers were men.

But some early-childhood experts say that while the hysteria around child sex abuse sparked by high-profile cases like that of Peter Ellis, who was accused of abusing children at the Christchurch Civic Childcare Centre, may contribute to the lack of men in the profession, the focus on one problem is hiding other barriers.

"The issue is really complex and I don't think the Peter Ellis stuff is really up there," early-childhood educator at Canterbury University Alex Gunn said.

"The low status of child-care work, low pay and the perception of it being a career for women all put off men from going into early-childhood work."

Farquhar acknowledged there were other issues to be considered, saying it was "time to see the hysteria and moral panic for what it was -- a panic".

"Debate on men in early-childhood teaching is needed in New Zealand," she said in her report.

"The veil of sexism inherent in the profession, due to it being a site for feminist activism and continued promulgation of the idea that men are not safe to work with young children, needs to be lifted and discussed."

Lynda Boyd, director of early-childhood teacher education at the Christchurch College of Education, said she was lucky to see 10 male students in an intake of 500.

"When I started at the college I would get four or five men just in my tutorial group.

"Now we are only getting four or five in the whole course," she said.

At Kidsfirst Kindergartens, just seven of the 240-strong teaching staff are male.

"I took over in 1995 and I think we have more men than we did then," chief executive Sherryll Wilson said.

"They bring a different angle to teaching. They are given a lot of support and I think that helps."