Allegations of Sexual Abuse


Police Rape Allegations - Main Index


Page 15 - Trial Verdict 2006

 




The Dominion Post
April 1 2006

A long and tortuous trial for all

The news dropped like a bomb. Louise Nicholas, mother of three, had accused one of the country's top police officers, Assistant Police Commissioner Clint Rickards, 45, and former policemen Bradley Shipton, 53, and Robert Schollum, 47, of raping her six to 12 times, including with a police baton.

From that moment the lives of the complainant, the accused, their families and friends, police officers and other rape complainants were turned on their head.

The allegations rocked the police to the core and prompted prime ministerial intervention. Within days, Helen Clark announced a commission of inquiry. Police, who some years before had investigated the same allegations, announced they were reopening their investigation. Rickards was stood down. He has not been back to work since, but has continued to receive his full salary, estimated to be about $200,000 a year.

Operation Austin, under the control of Superintendent Nick Perry, reinvestigated the allegations. It took a team of 20 detectives a year before deciding whether to lay charges. It took a further year to bring the case to trial. That first year alone involved 2000 interviews and cost police $1.6 million in staffing costs. The commission of inquiry has cost more than $1.4 million.

But the human cost is harder to gauge. What angst has gone on behind closed doors? What secrets revealed, events explained, promises made or broken since the news broke?

For Mrs Nicholas, the hardest thing was telling her story to her daughters, the youngest of whom was nine at the time. Her husband broke down in court as he gave evidence.

The three accused were forced to confront their accuser and watch helplessly as versions of their intimate past were shared with all of New Zealand. Their children, parents and partners sat in court listening as their sex lives were detailed in cold, intricate, grubby detail.

The toll has also been high on the team of detectives investigating the case. Some have spent months away from their families.

Mrs Nicholas had her day in court, spending almost six hours in the stand telling her story over and over.

Shipton and Schollum did not take the stand. A defiant Rickards did.

"Louise Nicholas is a liar," he told the court. He rebutted the prosecutor's suggestion that he was in cahoots with the other accused, that they had concocted their story. "There is no conflict when you tell the truth."

It was a case that intrigued the public, who watched it closely. Everyone had an opinion.

But the one that counts was the one delivered by the jury yesterday.