Allegations of abuse by NZ Police

peterellis Home / police allegations / Rickards, Shipton, Schollum vs Jane Doe

Page 4 - Initial Reaction to Not Guilty Verdict

 




Dominion Post
March 2 2007; 11:00

Rickards would 'find it hard' to regain support

Suspended Assistant Police Commissioner Clint Rickards has vowed to be back at work soon, but he faces an uphill battle winning back the support of frontline police and the public.

Employment law expert Peter Cullen said Mr Rickards, acquitted yesterday in a second police sex case alongside two former colleagues, had been "very unwise" to publicly label the investigation and prosecution effort against him a shambles.

Outside court after the verdict was read, Mr Rickards said Operation Austin was "a shambles and a poorly run operation, poorly run."

This criticism was directed at members of the same police force he says he wishes to return to.

Mr Rickards will remain suspended, as he has been for three years, while police sort through employment issues.

Deputy Police Commissioner Rob Pope said this would take "some time" but police would move as quickly as possible.

Mr Pope said the allegations against Mr Rickards were very serious and had been of concern to all police. "The last three years have been a difficult time for everyone concerned - for the complainant, the defendant and his family and the police inquiry team," he said.

Mr Cullen said Mr Rickards' comments about looking forward to returning to work as soon as possible could be seen as either putting pressure on police to have him return to his role as assistant commissioner, or, possibly setting the stage for negotiating an exit package.

But his attack on the investigation team appeared damaging to either approach.

Mr Rickards has been paid over $600,000 since he was stood down, continuing to receive police perks while studying law at Auckland University.

Mr Rickards, estimated to be earning around $200,000 a year, was stood down in February 2004 - three days after The Dominion Post revealed allegations by Rotorua woman Louise Nicholas.

Though he was not allowed to work, he kept his rank and continues to receive the pay and perks that were part of his employment conditions, including a police-issue Holden Commodore - with the police radios removed.

He enjoyed a meteoric rise through police ranks, from police cadet aged 18 in 1979, to undercover cop within three years, to assistant commissioner and Auckland district commander.

Mr Cullen said that, if Mr Rickards was reinstated, the one-time high-flying Maori policing role model would find it difficult to resume his leadership position within the police.

Fellow police officers, and the New Zealand public, had heard details of his sexual exploits with Mrs Nicholas, then a teenager, in Rotorua in the 1980s. Even though he was acquitted of rape in that case in March last year, he did admit to consensual sex with Mrs Nicholas. The young police officer had a partner and two children at the time of his affair with Mrs Nicholas.

Veteran lawyer Rob Moodie, who represented former senior police officer Alec Waugh in a bitter employment case, said reinstated police were traditionally ostracised on their return to the force.

They were not taken into confidence by superiors and would be cut out of conversations. Junior police did not have the same respect for them after they heard details of their superior's sexual history and saw them bringing the force into disrepute.

"I think Mr Rickards can expect much the same treatment. It will be very difficult for him. It's always difficult for anybody to have a shadow cast over their personal qualities."

Mr Rickards has not received any legal aid and revealed yesterday that he had spent more than $500,000 defending himself on sex charges.

Before this trial started, Shipton and Schollum, who both left the police in the 1990s, had received legal aid worth nearly $250,000 defending the Louise Nicholas case and other costs.