Allegations of abuse by NZ Police

peterellis Home / police allegations / Rickards, Shipton, Schollum vs Jane Doe

Page 6 - Further Reaction to Not Guilty Verdict

 





The Dominion Post
March 6 2007; 05:00

Pressure builds against Rickards
Clark raises questions about sexual consent
by Vernon Small

Helen Clark has stepped up the pressure against Clint Rickards' return as Auckland police commander, saying no reasonable person would consider group sex between three policemen and a teenager as genuinely consensual.

Miss Clark's comments make it almost impossible for Mr Rickards to hold a position of authority without undermining Government support for the police.

That was underlined yesterday when National Party leader John Key and Auckland Mayor Dick Hubbard spoke out against Mr Rickards' reinstatement.

Miss Clark said she would not comment on the future of an individual because Mr Rickards' future, following his acquittal on all charges against him, was an employment matter between him and the police.

"I believe the police will want to be very careful in following the proper process on this."

Mr Key called for Mr Rickards to leave the force. Mr Rickards had criticised the police inquiry, and said Brad Shipton and Bob Schollum, who were convicted of a separate rape in 1989, should not be in prison.

"It is hard to believe he has faith in the judicial process or that the public have faith in him," Mr Key said.

Miss Clark said she was appalled by what she had read during the trials of Mr Rickards and former policemen Shipton and Schollum.

"While there may be a legal meaning to the term consent, I have to question whether there can be any genuine consent when you have police officers in a position of responsibility in a community engaging in group sex with a teenage girl," she said.

"In my opinion no reasonable person would think ... there are really issues of consent here."

Shipton, Schollum and Mr Rickards were acquitted last week of charges of kidnapping and indecent assault of a 16-year-old girl more than 20 years ago. Last year they were acquitted of sex charges against Rotorua woman Louise Nicholas.

Asked about Mr Rickards' four promotions, after police became aware of claims against him, Miss Clark said: "The mind boggles."

Shipton and Schollum are in prison for the rape of a Mt Maunganui woman 18 years ago, but this was not revealed to the jury in last week's case.

Miss Clark said she favoured the Law Commission considering whether the rules of evidence should allow juries to be told about prior convictions.

A report into police culture by Dame Margaret Bazley, which was put on hold during the trials, would be issued in a few weeks.

Miss Clark said a minority in the police clearly indulged in actions that were completely unacceptable.

"I do feel extremely sorry for the overwhelming majority of good hardworking cops who totally deserve the faith the community puts in them."

A group of women who handed out flyers last year containing suppressed information about the Louise Nicholas trial are organising a march in Wellington on Thursday in support of rape victims.