The Christchurch Civic Crèche Case

News Reports Index

1992



The Press
September 4 1992

Anger over creche closing
by Michael Rentoul

The Christchurch Civic Child Care Centre was abruptly closed yesterday, angering staff and parents, after the Ministry of Education withdrew its operating licence.

The decision, which follows a police briefing with ministry officials, has left 13 staff redundant.

Staff learned of the decision from the City Manager. Mr John Gray who visited the centre at closing time yesterday.

The decision to close the centre was supported by Mr Gray, who was also briefed by the police.

The ministry said it revoked the licence because it believed the centre no longer complied with the Early Childhood Regulations.

The decision follows a glowing report on the centre's management last November by the Education Review Office. This report was presented to the council last March.

The ministry's South Island field manager, Mr Michael Deaker, said he moved to suspend the licence yesterday morning after being briefed by the police.

He would not comment on whether the briefing related to a police inquiry into sexual abuse at the centre.

A former employee at the centre has been charged with sexual offences against children, aged two to four, at the centre between November 1988 and March 1991. He was remanded last month to a pre-depositions hearing on October 5.

Mr Deaker said the council was legally entitled to make "representations" on the decision, should it have wanted to keep the centre open. However, Mr Gray had said that none would be forthcoming.

Mr Deaker said: "The suspension was notified to the city management this morning. They promptly responded by saying they had no deputations to make, so I took the next step to cancel that licence. It will be published in the 'Education Gazette' in due course."

Detectives had indicated that suspending the licence was the. the most appropriate thing to do, he said. The interests of the children were paramount"

Council staff were last night contacting the 30 to 60 parents with children at the centre.

Parents have been sent a list of alternative child-care centres. Most children are regulars as opposed to drop-in users.

The Local Government Officers' Union was last night considering its options for challenging the ministry's decision.

Its secretary, Mr Peter Lawson, said the ministry should be held to account. The decision had yet to be explained to staff, many of whom were distraught

After speaking to Mr Lawson last night, Mr Gray formally withdrew the notices of redundancy issued earlier. Instead, he has placed staff on two weeks paid leave.

Redeployment options will be considered at a meeting of council staff and the union today.

Parents who contacted "The Press" last night said they were aghast at the decision to close, and angry about the lack of notice.

One parent said the only explanation given for the sudden closing was that the ministry had withdrawn the licence.

Two parents said they thought the decision was politically motivated by the council, which in last year's budget round tried to have the centre closed.

One father said it took months for his child to become settled at the centre.

"Our wee boy absolutely loves the place, and he is supposed to be going there tomorrow morning. Then they drop a "bombshell like this overnight."

The head of the centre's management committee, Mr Simon Fraser, said parents would seek the ministry's explanation for the move.

Parents were "tremendously upset" about the decision, and would seek the council's support in having the licence reinstated, he said.

He had not been alerted to ant recent police concerns about the centre, he said.