The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

1992



The Press
December 4, 1992

Mother wanted abuse expert's aid


The mother of an alleged child victim of sexual abuse wanted an overseas expert in ritualistic abuse called in to help with the Christchurch Civic Childcare Centre inquiry, the preliminary hearing in the District Court was told yesterday.

In a letter to the police sent in August, the woman said she wanted an overseas author on ritualistic abuse, Ms Pamela Hudson, brought to New Zealand to discuss the subject.

The mother, whose name is suppressed, said during cross-examination she had grave concerns as to whether anyone in New Zealand had sufficient expertise to deal with children who had been ritually abused, and their families.

Five former staff are accused of sexually abusing some of the children who attended the creche.

Peter Hugh McGregor Ellis, aged 34, faces 45 indecency charges. The former manager of the creche, Gaye Jocelyn Davidson, aged 39, Janice Virginia Buckingham, aged 44, and Marie Keys, aged 44, each face four charges. Deborah Janet Gillespie, aged 30, faces three charges.

The witness said the person counselling her son had indicated that it could be helpful to have an expert in ritualistic abuse brought in to assist.

Counsel for the Crown, Mr Chris Lange, said the question of ritualistic abuse did not form any part of the Crown's case against the defendants.

Cross-examined by counsel for the four women, Mr Gerald Nation, the mother said she had not considered the possibility that ritual abuse had taken place until her son mentioned it.

She said her son had mentioned a group of Asian men, five teenagers and 22 other people whom he alleged had abused children.

He had spoken of a visit to a church where he said two children had been made to dress up and marry each other. When asked if he had been forced to take part in the marriage, he threw a tantrum and walked out of the room. He later returned to the room and said he had something to say.

The witness said her son talked freely about what he said had happened to other children, but found it extremely painful to talk about what happened to him. He became agitated when events he was describing were painful for him.

She said her son had talked to her about a graveyard where he said he was placed in a cage with a cat, and left for 30 minutes. He also said a friend of Ellis's had been put in a box and buried in the-ground.

The mother said she had been advised by the police not to ask leading questions of her son and had asked direct questions. She did not think these had been leading questions.

She said the thought of her son having been abused had caused her considerable distress and anger. The hardest part had been keeping herself in complete control and not revealing her anxiety to her son.

The witness said she had been upset and angry when the specialist services unit of the Department of Social Welfare cancelled a scheduled interview with her son in August. She understood this was done because she had questioned her son about alleged abuse before the interview was due to take place.

She said she believed she and her partner had done a particularly good job in making their son feel safe and secure, enabling him to speak to a stranger about things which were painful to him.

She said she had had some social contact with other parents who had children at the creche. This began after her son first disclosed alleged abuse.

She said she believed she had an obligation to tell parents of children named by her son as having being abused, despite police advice to the contrary.

The contact with other parents helped her survive and cope with what was happening.

The hearing of depositions, to decide if the accused will be sent for trial, is not expected to finish until the end of January.