The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Home


1997 Index

 





The Evening Standard
November 17, 1997

Abuse fear scaring men off
by Lee Matthews



Men are still avoiding caring for young children as jobs because of the fear of being accused of child abuse, says a Massey University academic.

Early education expert Sarah Farquhar says that, at best, men practise defensive caregiving to guard against allegations of child abuse.

Dr Farquhar, commenting on last night's 20/20 television feature about the 1993 case of Christchurch childcare worker Peter Ellis, convicted of child abuse, said most male teachers would welcome a move to clear Ellis's name.

Earlier this year, Dr Farquhar released a study which showed that fear of being accused of child abuse was the key reason men either dropped out of or never began kindergarten or childcare work.

A number of men, especially in childcare centres, left their jobs at the time of the Ellis case.

"It has meant that sensitive, caring and competent men willing to work in early years education are not being encouraged and supported," she said.

Society was suffering because children were now unlikely to have a male teacher until high school. Since 1992, the number of men in preschool services dropped from 2.1 to 1.4 percent. The gender gap in primary school teaching was also growing, with 7.2 percent fewer male teachers now than in 1991.

On the positive side, the men who were teaching preschool did so because they really wanted to. They had not been put off by the sector's low wages or lack of career structure, Dr Farquhar said.

More men were needed in the area, to make sure children got the message that men were as capable and as caring towards preschoolers as women were, she said.