The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Home


1997 Index

 





The Dominion
December 2, 1997

Hundreds falsely accused, says group
by Annie Gray


A Ministerial inquiry is being called for into cases where men have been convicted of sexual offences on the basis of uncorroborated testimonies.

Casualties of Sexual Allegations Inc, or Cosa, is seeking the inquiry. Cosa president Felicity Goodyear-Smith says that while the Peter Ellis case in Christchurch has attracted a great deal of media attention, there are many innocent people who have been falsely accused in less sensational abuse cases.

She says she has on record dozens of cases where men have been convicted on the basis of uncorroborated testimony and she points the finger at an ideology which assumes that women and children always tell the truth.

Cosa was set up four years ago and has 350 members, two-thirds of whom are people directly involved with false allegations. Others are friends and family of accused people or interested professionals.

Dr Goodyear-Smith concedes that her group has no way of knowing whether any of its members are guilty, but she says members can often produce cases where the evidence overwhelmingly points to their innocence.

Cosa aims to offer support to people falsely accused and to disseminate information about the policies and practices they believe have been inherited from the United States, along with lobbying to change legislative issues surrounding sexual abuse cases.

In the 1980s Dr Goodyear-Smith was a GP often working with the police in examining victims of sexual abuse. She was involved in establishing the HELP Foundation for sexual abuse victims.

She says that while there was a need for changes to be made to the way abuse victims were treated, the pendulum has now swung too far in the complainants' favour.

Dr Goodyear-Smith is married to John Potter, son of Centrepoint founder Bert Potter who is serving a nine-year prison sentence for perjury, child sex and drugs charges. John Potter spent four months in jail in 1993 for indecent assault involving two under-age girls at Centrepoint. Dr Goodyear-Smith says he was aged about 20 at the time. She met him after that time and has never been a member of the Centrepoint community.

She says she is not unaware of the irony of the situation, but she had started speaking out about these issues years ago, and while she would prefer someone else to pursue the issue, no one else has taken up the challenge.

She says a change in approach means complainants are always believed. She blames an ideology imported from the United States which covers training, literature and protocol for dealing with abuse cases.

"Implicitly now, we believe them (the complainant) . . . we have case after case after case of what I see as people accused on the basis of uncorroborated testimony."

Dr Goodyear-Smith says that in the past the judge in an abuse case had to warn of the dangers of convicting where there was no corroborating evidence, but that legislation was changed in 1986. Cosa would like it reinstated. "I think the police will admit that cases now come to trial which would not have got past the front counter in the past . . . there is a lot of pressure now to believe the complainants."

Detective Inspector John Doyle of the Christchurch CIB says that in all cases, including sex abuse cases, the facts have to be established before going any further. He says that when a complaint of sex abuse is received police will investigate it. If the complaint is untrue this will surface and not every case brought to the police gets to court. He says that the changing environment in the past 10 to 15 years has meant that more people are coming forward.

Police evidential interviewer Constable Karen Vaughan, of Wellington Central, says that of 179 cases she has interviewed there has been only one retraction. And at the end of each interview, she says, complainants are given the chance to retract or change anything.

As an interviewer, Ms Vaughan says, she is careful not to offer positive reinforcement. She says all cases are fully investigated before coming to trial.

Ms Vaughan says there is probably too much emphasis put on children making false complaints. The police prefer to see children as soon as a complaint has been made and before they have been through intensive therapy. A lengthy period of therapy can make the task of establishing complaint details more difficult, she says.

Dr Goodyear-Smith says several of the cases her group sees involve acrimonious custody disputes where a mother has accused an estranged husband. She says that the Family Court does not need to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt and many fathers end up with supervised access only.

"This is very painful for them and incredibly destructive for the children."

A spokesman from the Department for Courts, Barry Ebert, says that allegations of sexual abuse have to be backed by evidence before the Family Court will deny access or impose supervised access. While the Family Court does apply a different test, basically there has to be enough evidence to persuade the court there is a real risk to the child.

Dr Goodyear-Smith says that she has cases where fathers who have been charged and acquitted of sexual abuse in the criminal courts are still denied access to their children.

One man is denied access to his daughter because, while it is accepted there has never been abuse, his daughter is "so contaminated" by the process that she has come to believe she has been abused and is afraid to be with her father.

Dr Goodyear-Smith says she is also concerned that current ideology assumes some behaviour in children is automatically the result of sexual abuse and that there is little perception on just how easy it is to feed ideas to children. She says children who deny any abuse are not believed.

However, she says, interviewing techniques have vastly improved and there is a lot more knowledge now about suggestive techniques.