The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Home


1998 Index

 





The Press
March 13 1998

Ellis snubs parole board
by Elinore Wellwood

Mother backs convicted sex abuser's stand

Convicted child abuser Peter Ellis will not accept freedom from prison if it is granted on the basis that he is a guilty man.

Yesterday he sent a letter to the parole board refusing to appear for his first chance of freedom from a jail cell in four years and nine months.

The first his nervous mother heard about his decision was when she got out to Rolleston Prison yesterday morning to be his support person.

``He told me, `I can't do this. It's an acceptance I'm guilty' .''

Mrs Ellis said she could see he was at peace with his decision.

She said she felt a bit tearful. ``It's not nice having part of your family in prison. But he can't come out and live with himself if he just walks out for the sake of freedom.''

From her home in Christchurch last night, Ellis's tired mother said her son's innocence meant too much for him to accept freedom on the basis that he accepted guilt.

Ellis had consistently refused courses and counselling offered in prison because a large component involved addressing the offending -- and he was innocent, Mrs Ellis said.

The parole board hearing went ahead without Ellis and he will find out late next week if he will spend his 40th birthday, this month, in Christchurch's Rolleston Prison.

He was jailed for 10 years after being found guilty of sexually abusing children at the Christchurch Civic Childcare Centre between 1986 and 1992.

His lawyer, Judith Ablett-Kerr, said: ``Any release at this stage would inevitably mean a release on parole subject to certain conditions. Such a release is not compatible with his fight to have his convictions overturned.''

A petition to overturn his convictions is still before Governor-General Sir Michael Hardie Boys.

Mrs Ablett-Kerr said Ellis had maintained his innocence since he was first accused.

``He continues to maintain his innocence and, whilst he is most anxious to regain his freedom and to return to his family and friends, he cannot accept that freedom if it is granted on the basis that he is a guilty man.''

Ellis had made no application to go before the board, she said.

Mrs Ellis said her son seemed calm and peaceful after weeks of nervousness leading up to the parole board hearing.

When she got to the prison he said he had been speaking to Mrs Ablett-Kerr. They had gone over the options open to him.

Mrs Ellis said that after she got over her surprise at his decision she agreed it was right.

She said her son's actions were very brave.

Ellis surprised her in many ways, she said. ``He was quite calm about it. The decision to do what he did took a big weight off his shoulders.''

She said all her son was saying was that at this moment parole was not appropriate. He would like to wait for the petition decision.

Ellis, herself, and supporters wanted two things, Mrs Ellis said.

They wanted an answer to the petition and an inquiry into the Christchurch civic creche case.

She said she would stand behind him the whole way, whatever his decision was.

``We all stand by his innocence.''

Peter Ellis had a high level of support from other prisoners, she said.

He had gone back to his Rolleston prison cell not just for himself, but also for other prisoners who had been treated unjustly.

He also went back for everyone else involved in the Christchurch civic creche case, she said.

The parole board said in a statement that it was bound by law to consider the cases of inmates eligible for parole who wished to appear before it. It would reconsider each case at least once every 12 months.

Gaye Davidson, who was jointly accused with Ellis of abusing children at the civic creche, said she was amazed at his strength.

She was discharged from the accusations levelled at her in court. ``The chance of freedom -- can you imagine turning that down when you are an innocent person?''

She said Ellis's innocence meant so much to him that he was not going to sell it short.

``He's stronger than I would have been.''

She said her initial amazement that he had turned down the chance to be heard by the parole board had turned to acceptance. ``When he's done it, it's the sort of thing you would expect of him.''

She said she could see why he had done it.

``We all stand by his innocence. He shouldn't be there. He should not be in prison.''

Ellis supporter Winston Wealleans said refusing to go before the parole board was the only option open to Ellis but ``if the parole board says he has to go, he will go under protest''.

``The important thing is the petition.''

He said there was evidence to show the case was not conducted properly.

--------------------

CAPTION:  PHOTO: JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON Peter Ellis's mother, Lesley, stands behind her son's decision to turn down his first chance at freedom.