The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Home


1998 Index

 





The Dominion
March 18 1998

Crèche detective gets reply in Parliament
NZPA

The detective in charge of the Christchurch civic crèche case whose behaviour was raised in Parliament has been allowed comments in his defence written into the House's record.

Last November, at a select committee and in the debating chamber, MPs expressed doubt about the conduct and outcome of the crèche investigation and in particular the propriety of the officer in charge of the case, Colin Eade, having had relationships with the mothers of two child complainants.

Mr Eade's response, presented to Parliament yesterday by Speaker Doug Kidd, is only the third time the procedure has been used since the process became available in 1995.

In November, after the airing of a 20/20 television documentary, Labour's Phil Goff raised in Parliament his doubts about the guilt of Peter Ellis, who is midway through a 10-year jail sentence for child abuse.

In particular, Mr Goff raised questions centred on Mr Eade having had intimate relationships with the mothers of two of the crèche children, and having suffered from psychological difficulties.

Mr Eade's response was presented yesterday under a section of Parliament's Standing Orders, which allows people who consider their reputation has been damaged in Parliament to apply to the Speaker for their response to be included in the parliamentary record.

Mr Eade's successful application is only the third to have been accepted -- the first was from Applefields and the second from Tobacco Institute executive director Michael Thompson.

Mr Eade's response said that at the start of the inquiry he had been in the child abuse unit for 18 months, which was stressful and he was due for a break.

The inquiry into the crèche was "very difficult and stressful, not only for me but for all investigators who joined the inquiry team".

"I later left the police after 19 years' service because of a condition arising from the stress. I never wanted to leave but I had no choice."

Mr Eade said he did not leave till the inquiry was over.

He said that at no time during the inquiry was he involved in a relationship with anyone associated with the case.

"During the four years that followed I had relationships with two single mothers who had children at the civic crèche.

"One parent had been part of the prosecution case but didn't live in Christchurch at the time of the inquiry.

"The other parent had no part in the prosecution."

* Police visit crèche p11