The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

1999 Jan-June



The Dominion
March 18 1999

Ellis loses out in parole bid

by Joanna Norris

Convicted Christchurch civic creche child abuser Peter Ellis has been denied parole for the second time.

Ellis, who is serving a 10-year sentence for 16 child abuse charges, said through his lawyer last night that he was concerned about the progress of the pending investigation into his case.

Ellis appeared before the Parole Board last week and it was announced yesterday that parole had been denied.

He is due to be freed from prison in February next year when he will have served the mandatory two-thirds of his sentence.

His lawyer, Judith Ablett Kerr, QC, said Ellis was "in no way taken by surprise" by yesterday's decision.

"What he does feel is anxiety. Anxiety as to whether Thomas Thorp's inquiry gets dealt with in time and whether all the issues in his petitions are investigated fully."

Ellis's case is being examined by former High Court judge Sir Thomas Thorp, who is advising Governor-General Sir Michael Hardie Boys on a petition calling for Ellis's pardon.

Mrs Ablett Kerr said the Parole Board could only deal with Ellis as if he had committed an offence and at the time of the hearing their positions were "irreconcilable".

Ellis had maintained his innocence from the beginning and would continue to do so, she said.

At the hearing, Ellis presented a short statement that said he could not accept any parole because the board could only free him as a guilty man.

In the board decision Justice Heron said the board had made it clear that the attitude of the inmate and steps taken to avoid future offending were considered by the board when decisions were made.

He said Ellis had maintained his innocence, "as he is entitled to do so", but as a result had not undertaken any courses or programmes.

Justice Heron said the jury's verdict and judge's sentence compelled the board to consider the case as very serious offending against children and it could not go behind the verdict and sentence.

He said it would be impossible to grant parole without conditions restricting access to young children.

When Ellis was next before the board, in December, it would be likely such conditions would be imposed on Ellis when he was freed from prison next February.