The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

1999 Jan-June



Sunday Star Times
March 28 1999

Or a farce
Letter to the Editor
by Robert Perry, Wellington

The letter from Sarah Smuts-Kennedy (March 21), misinterpreting Frank Haden's column about Peter Ellis as an assertion that children who claim to have been sexually abused should be disbelieved, counters by saying children will continue to be sexually abused "until society starts believing" them.

This attitude -- that children's accusations should be taken as gospel -- not only renders hypocritical her description of Haden's remarks as "bold statements", but is also one of the main reasons why males are terrified to enter the teaching profession.

In such situations neither side deserves to be either believed or disbelieved, and after the typically homophobic investigation and farcical trial to which Ellis was subjected this remains the case.

If I, like the likes of Smuts-Kennedy, arrogantly regarded wrongful conviction for paedophilia as less serious than paedophilia itself, I too would be happy to moronically interpret the findings of Ellis's jury as irrevocable fact.