The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

1999 Jan-June



Sunday Star Times
May 9 1999

Finding strength in a family crisis
by Peter Hawes

I suspect we are one gob-smacked little nation after last week, reeling from the revelations of the Inside NZ documentary Relative Guilt (TV3, Wednesday). For the first time we met the extended family of a certain well-known New Zealander -- and what fine folks they transpired to be; eloquent, well-educated and liberal.

Our celebrity came from a family of 13. Ten brothers and three sisters. All -- we were told -- were put through the private Catholic school system by a father who laboured 15 hours a day to give his kids the best start possible in life.

We met also the lovingly devoted wife of our celebrity, and his two fine sons whose intelligence and dignity again reflected on the high ideals of their parents. However, the family -- both extended and nuclear -- was under intense stress, and has been for 10 years. For the celebrity in question is David Tamihere.

More facts about David Tamihere, I venture, came out in this hour-long documentary, than in his trial and its appeals: that he even had a wife, for example, and two boys. That he looks quite spiffing in a dark suit and shrewdly analyses TV comedians (during his weekly 15-minute phonecall home). These were hitherto unknown sides to the guy who has been built into our awareness as a sort of feral Mike Tyson-cum-Elephant Man of the northern bush, invariably handcuffed -- for our protection -- to a self-important cop.

This horror story has never been officially addressed and has been left to fade slowly, like the grin of the Cheshire cat. As have, of course, the stories of Tamihere's equally famous co-villain Peter Ellis, in which, if I remember, Ellis transported 2000 naked boys to a UFO parked behind comet Globbit-Spry where he poured tadpole jelly into their belly buttons while singing Bad to the Devil on ET's cellphone.

I don't even think my preposterous example is as wacky as some of those bandied around Christchurch at the time of Ellis's arrest; all which were widely believed, and officially investigated. And while pondering this, remember the famous remark by the judge at the Yorkshire Ripper trial: "The most frightening aspect of this trial, is that you (Ripper) are not insane." Yep, folks, let's face it, we're nuts and the crims are sane.

I'll prove it by personal reference to the Tamihere case: I remember being horrified when a Swedish body was found, and on its wrist was a watch Tamihere was supposed to have stolen. "Ye gods!" I yelped to my equally ashen pub mates, "he'll get off, and then, mad as hell, he'll come after us all!" I regained equanimity only when Tamihere's appeal was rejected and he was clamped safely away again. I was secretly unsure he'd had a fair suck of the sav, but he was a "monster" and just too evil to be out here.

How I'd gained that impression, I forget. Whether it had been intentionally created I will never know. All I do know is I daily saw the beautiful face of the Swedish girl, juxtaposed with the swarthy Quasimodo of David Tamihere. Where was the splendid photo of him in his black suit with his sons, just for a change?

The younger son, Craig -- who, at nine was given a new identity for a while, has gone inwards and is angry -- but nobly so. The elder son, John, in a poignant metaphor, has become a clown who masks up and brings happiness to others. Tamihere's wife said, "I've done 10 years of his life sentence too, and we're still a family."

While there's fusion in the nuclear family, there's been a bit of fission in the extended one; the depradations of the IRD and Social Welfare on cousins and uncles has taken a toll on family unity. A toll most now regret.

The de-demonising of David Tamihere was a trial for all who watched, for it was unlikely to have overturned many verdicts in people's minds. But while he has caused his family to "walk down the aisle of cameras, going off so loud I can hear them to this day" -- the cameras of TV3 showed us an embattledly close group of good people who have never had a monster in their midst.