The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

1999 July-Dec



The Dominion
September 24 1999

Ellis's mother asks Ryall for commission of inquiry
by Alan Samson

 

Lesley Ellis, mother of convicted child abuser Peter Ellis, made her strongest appeal yet yesterday on behalf of her son, delivering a written plea to Justice Minister Tony Ryall for a royal commission of inquiry.

Mrs Ellis's letter to Mr Ryall, together with letters calling for support to every other member of Parliament, were received on Parliament steps by NZ First leader Winston Peters and party whip Ron Mark.

Ellis's case is awaiting judgment from the Court of Appeal. Should the appeal be declined and Mr Ryall consent to an inquiry, it would be unlikely any action could be taken before Ellis was freed from prison.

He is due out, automatically, after two-thirds of his sentence has been served, in February.

Asked if this was a last-ditch attempt to free her son, Mrs Ellis said: "I've been doing this for eight years, I'm not going to give up now."

Yesterday, Ellis was to have been let out on home leave from Christchurch prison. Consistent with his stance before the Parole Board, he had declined that leave, she said.

He would also decline Christmas Day leave should it be offered -- Mrs Ellis had recently been visited by authorities to judge if her home was "suitable" for a Christmas visit.

But Ellis, convicted in 1993 on 13 abuse charges at Christchurch's civic centre creche, maintained his innocence and would not relent his stance.

Mr Peters said he supported an inquiry because he held grave concerns about some aspects of the case, and an inquiry should proceed even after Ellis was freed.

"I don't see why someone should go through life a convicted felon if they're innocent," he said.

Mrs Ellis's letter questions the narrowness of focus of two appeal hearings.

"I have learned from the appeal that other countries have recognised the need for special care in creche-type cases and Australia has held a royal commission of inquiry that included identifying the dangers associated with the prosecution of mass hysteria creche-type cases," she says.

"Why as a country do we in New Zealand lag behind?"

A Court of Appeal registry spokeswoman said there had been no indication of an appeal decision. The appeal hearing ended on July 8.

A spokesman for Mr Ryall would only say that the appeal for an inquiry would be considered.