The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports

1999



The Dominion
October 15 1999

Ellis camp vows to fight `for justice'
by Alan Samson

Lesley Ellis, mother of convicted child abuser Peter Ellis, was "angry but unsurprised" yesterday that her son was to stay behind bars.

The Court of Appeal's decision to uphold Ellis's convictions for child abuse had not been unexpected, Mrs Ellis said.

The defence team and her son's supporters were angry that the ruling had been based on a contraction of the evidence.

"The court was offered 150,000 pages of evidence presented as 500 pages, but then Judith (defence counsel Judith Ablett-Kerr, QC,) was told to present that in 40.

"That's less than the (48 pages) they've taken to give the judgment. They've used up more paper to say `no'."

Inquiries in Australia and the United States had recognised the problem with trials involving ritual-satanic abuse allegations, but it seemed that in New Zealand nobody wanted to know, she said.

"The best we can do now is ask the public to write to their MPs asking for a commission of inquiry . . . I'm certain there are enough people to push to find another way of getting justice, other than through the judiciary."

Representing Ellis's supporters yesterday, his friend Barry Doyle said he felt helpless and disappointed.

"I feel that they're still dealing with the judicial process rather than justice," he said.

"We've been through another door but there will be other doors to be knocked on . . . this can't be allowed to end because Peter is innocent and innocence has its own voice."

Mrs Ablett-Kerr said the decision made it clear that the issues were more fitting for a commission of inquiry.

"The appellate structure is not designed to cope with this case. The appellate structure is designed to look at process and procedure.

"A commission of inquiry goes beyond that."

Asked if she was disappointed that the court had not looked beyond questions of law and processes, she said: "The court felt that it couldn't. That's why I've asked the governor-general for a free pardon and to have a royal commission of inquiry."

The battle to clear Ellis's name would go on, she said. "The Ellis files are still open, the truth is still out there."

* Push for pardon p3