The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports

1999



Sunday Star Times
October 31 1999

A scapegoat
Letter to the Editor
by Dennis Horne, Auckland

THE Peter Ellis case is disturbing. Coney and Haden (October 24) have forceful and irreconcilable opinions. What are we left with? Guilty or innocent? Was the conviction sound?

It is outrageous that discarded police evidence could not be presented by the defence. In the search for truth, one cannot simply hide findings that don't fit.

Guilty or innocent, Ellis was the scapegoat for a botched investigation and the victim of a poor-quality trial. That, at least, is obvious.

And we can't correct this? Words fail me.