The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2002 July-Dec Index



The Dominion Post
July 20, 2002

Fresh crèche abuse claims
by David McLoughlin

Police want to talk to Peter Ellis about fresh allegations of sexual abuse of children dating from the time he worked at the Christchurch Civic Crèche more than a decade ago.

Two detectives visited Ellis at his Christchurch home on Wednesday evening to ask him to arrange a time for him and lawyer Judith Ablett-Kerr, QC, to see them at the police station.

It is understood the allegations come from a person in their late teens who attended the crèche while Ellis worked there between 1986 and 1991 and who has since been in therapy.

The police move comes on the eve of Dunedin writer Lynley Hood's book on the case, A City Possessed, being a prime contender for a Montana book awards prize at a ceremony in Auckland tonight.

In 1993, Ellis was convicted of 16 counts of abusing crèche children and sentenced to 10 years' jail. He was freed on automatic parole in February 2000. He has always maintained he is innocent.

An inquiry last year into aspects of the case by former chief justice Sir Thomas Eichelbaum found that Ellis had failed "by a distinct margin" to prove his innocence. But a secret report by another retired judge, Sir Thomas Thorp, looked at similar issues and concluded there was "serious doubt about the safety of (Ellis's) convictions". This report was leaked a week after Justice Minister Phil Goff issued the Eichelbaum report. Ellis supporter Winston Wealleans said last night that he was at Ellis's home on Wednesday when two detectives arrived at 6.50pm. Mr Wealleans said they asked Ellis to arrange an appointment at the police station for Ellis and Mrs Ablett-Kerr. Ellis asked if they could see him with his lawyer at home, but he was told they had to go to the station.

"They would not give any details of why they wanted to see him," Mr Wealleans said. "Peter asked if this was a historical case (of abuse from his crèche days) and they confirmed that it was."

The two detectives could not be reached for comment last night.

Canterbury University criminologist Greg Newbold spoke to Ellis yesterday about the new police move. Dr Newbold said last night that he had advised Ellis to invite police to prosecute him for the new allegations.

"Ninety per cent of people in Christchurch know he is innocent now, thanks to Lynley's book, and so does the judiciary. If they charged him with these new ones it is highly unlikely he would be convicted and it would show up the absurdity of the original case."

Mrs Ablett-Kerr is overseas.