The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2002 July-Dec Index



The Press
July 22, 2002

Book's award adds fuel to crèche case inquiry

The triumph of A City Possessed in the Montana New Zealand Book Awards adds fuel to calls for a Royal Commission of inquiry into the Christchurch Civic Crèche child abuse case. So says Dunedin author Lynley Hood, whose 600-page account of the controversial case won the premier literary award at the weekend.

A City Possessed headed both the Montana non-fiction and history categories, worth a total of $15,000.

"When the book first came out I remember a journalist saying to me that it had a slow-burning fuse," Hood said. "I guess the wins have made the fuse burn shorter and brighter. "The issue is going to have to be addressed because it's not going away and I hope this just helps to focus the minds of the politicians."

Hood spent seven years researching and writing the book, which claims there were flaws in the investigative and interviewing methods used to convict crèche worker Peter Ellis in 1993.

She was affronted that the concerns raised in her book continued to be ignored by the Government.

"Some people say `well, they'll never do anything because it's too big, because the ripples are spread so wide and so many careers and reputations are on the line.' "But I think if South Africa can deal with apartheid and move on without civil war breaking out, surely we can clean up the mess created by the crèche case."

Hood has joined Ellis supporters to call for a Royal Commission of inquiry into the case.

The convener of the judging panel, Witi Ihimaera, said A City Possessed was an extraordinary book which could not be ignored. "With great tenacity, Hood leads us to an understanding of how the events in Christchurch could have occurred. "(Her) courage in pursuing the book's publication has given us a narrative that, for all its controversy, makes it a stand-out not just in this year but in any year," Ihimaera said.

A City Possessed was also a clear winner of the coveted Reader's Choice Award.