The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2002 July-Dec Index



The Southland Times
July 24, 2002

Book on Ellis case
Letter to the Editor
by A J Lemm, Queenstown

Congratulations must go to Lynley Hood on being the overall winner of the Montana book award with A City Possessed, which covers the conviction of Peter Ellis in the Christchurch Civic Crèche case.

This book details how this fiasco came about and gives an insight into those involved. A few basic facts emerge; no factual evidence has ever been submitted as to Peter Ellis' guilt. The only evidence that has ever been given was of young children on carefully selected video tapes and their credibility could not be challenged under cross-examination. No one saw anything untoward at the crèche yet numerous people came and went.

Having read many of the reviews on the case, no one has refuted the book's contents. Also many eminent legal authorities endorsed the findings. The time has come for a full commission of inquiry on the subject.

Since the book was published, the Minister of Justice Phil Goff has taken a head-in-the-sand attitude and keeps fudging facts. Regardless of the implications of fallout, which will be immense, justice is the overriding factor. The only way the matter can be resolved is in truth and action by the Government.

With the election days away, perhaps people will consider justice that is not contaminated rather than corncobs.