The Christchurch Civic Creche Case

News Reports Index

2003 Oct-Dec



One News
December 10, 2003

Creche case before select committee

A select committee has heard submissions on whether concerns raised over the Peter Ellis case warrant a royal commission of inquiry.

The former Christchurch Civic Creche worker was found guilty in 1993 of offences against seven children.

The initial inquiry was sparked by two petitions with almost 4,000 signatures calling for the commission. The petitions were signed by many high profile New Zealanders - including former prime ministers, law professors, writers and psychologists.

Lynley Hood, the author of a book about the case - A City Possessed - told the committee there were serious flaws in the investigative techniques. She said the criminal justice process needed to be addressed.

She said the problems with the Ellis case have wide implications if they are not corrected.

The Ministry of Justice questioned the select committee as to whether there was any new information to warrant another inquiry.

Earlier this year Justice Minister Phil Goff said the case has already been well scrutinised by both the Court of Appeal and a former Chief Justice during the ministerial inquiry in 2001.