The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Main Index


2005 Index 3 (Aug 1-9)

 




One News
August 9 2005

Ellis case may go to the Privy Council
Transcript of News Report



Presenter:                  There's been a big setback for campaigners trying to clear the name of the man found guilty of molesting children at Christchurch's Civic Crèche. Peter Ellis won't get a commission of inquiry into his case, but a parliamentary committee has cleared the way for the case to go to the Privy Council.

 

Winston Wealleans:    But what about the investigation?

 

Announcer:                Thirteen years on and tensions still run high in Christchurch over the Civic Crèche case.

 

Winston Wealleans:    They're wanting to know what went wrong with the case.

 

Announcer:                 But after two years of deliberation news that there will be no commission of inquiry.  From the chairman of the Select Committee no apologies for how long it has taken.

 

Tim Barnett                I think our recommendations in total do everything which realistically a Royal Commission of Inquiry could have done, except we've done them some years quicker than would have otherwise been possible.

 

Announcer:                The committee is recommending some legal changes as a result of the case. It wants changes to the regulations covering the taking of video evidence from children; Changes to the Crimes Act to restrict the number of complainants listed on the indictments;  and the Royal Perogative of Mercy system be reformed. 

But that did not satisfy Ellis most ardent supporters.

 

Winston Wealleans     It's far too general. It's not specific. We wanted the Ellis thing sorted and solved.

 

Announcer:                But the news wasn't all bad for Ellis. The Committee has cleared the way for an appeal to the Privy Council.

 

Judith Ablett-Kerr       One has to be positive and that's the frankly an endorsement really for Peter to take his case to the Privy Council

 

Presenter:                  Peter Ellis told us he's disappointed the Select Committee won't recommend a Commission of inquiry but he is pleased an application to the Privy Council has been endorsed. He's also pleased with recommended changes to the law he says could help others.

Blair Norton, One News.