The Christchurch Civic Creche Case


News Reports - Main Index


2005 Index 3 (Aug 1-9)

 




The Southland Times
August 9 2005

Committee paves way for Ellis' appeal to Privy Council

Christchurch - A parliamentary inquiry into the Christchurch Civic Creche case has recommended the way be cleared for Peter Ellis to appeal to the Privy Council and for the taxpayer to pay for it.

Parliament's justice and electoral select committee yesterday released its long-awaited report into a petition by Ellis supporters, including National leader Don Brash, demanding an inquiry into the case.

The committee rejected a requested royal commission but recommended the Attorney General not oppose a new application by Mr Ellis for leave to appeal to the Privy Council and recommended the Legal Services Agency provide legal aid for the bid.

Mr Ellis said yesterday he was disappointed but not surprised the committee had denied his request for a royal commission of inquiry. He was pleased the committee's recommendations could in future help those falsely accused of sex crimes against children.

"The recommendations are good in a sense that they at least admit there were some problems in the way they (the court system) look at kids' testimony," he said.

Mr Ellis was convicted in 1993 on 16 sexual abuse charges based on the testimony of seven children who attended Christchurch's Civic Creche.

One of the children later withdrew her complaint during an appeal against his High Court convictions. Mr Ellis said he was considering an appeal to the Privy Council.

The release of the report two days before Parliament's closure meant its findings could be ignored by a new government, he said.

Justice and electoral select committee chairman Tim Barnett said the committee rejected the option of a royal commission because tweaking present laws would "do much more to improve the standards of justice in our community"

Dr Brash said he was disappointed the select committee had not ordered a royal commission but could not guarantee Mr Ellis would get a royal commission even if National won next month's election