Allegations of Abuse in NZ

peterellis Home / abuse allegations / Tea Ropati /

Page 3 - Not Guilty Verdict

Tea Ropati - League Star accused of rape
Not Guilty
”a case that should never have gone to trial” - Lawyer






http://www.nzherald.co.nz/topic/story.cfm?c_id=115&objectid=10489519

 

NZ Herald
January 30 2008; 05:00

 

Jury told not to blame woman in Ropati case
by Andrew Koubaridis

Tea Ropati.
Photo / Martin Sykes

An Auckland District Court jury has been told not to blame the woman at the centre of former league star Tea Ropati's sex trial but to focus on someone who had been taken advantage of while she was defenceless.

Ropati faces six charges of attempted sexual violation, sexual violation, rape, and sodomy, that allegedly occurred on June 15, 2006.

He denies all the charges.

In his summary of the case, prosecutor Phil Hamlin said it would be tempting to blame the woman for getting into trouble because she was drunk and had snorted cocaine, but the jury must not judge her.

"I'm sure it's passed through your minds, if not your discussions," Mr Hamlin said.

"But we are not here to judge her."

Mr Hamlin said the woman - who cannot be named for legal reasons - had been flirting and laughing with Ropati in the Whiskey Bar on Ponsonby Rd but later became sleepy and unresponsive when the pair moved to a back room where some of the alleged sexual offending took place.

Mr Hamlin said the law was clear that consent could not be given if someone was asleep or unconscious and that video footage of the pair in the bar showed the woman was clearly affected by alcohol, "curled up in a position of sleep or the very least resting". He said she was so impaired she wasn't able to consent to sex and all the evidence presented in court pointed to consent not being given.

"This is the essence of the complainant's case ... that she was taken advantage of and couldn't defend herself," he said.

After being in the bar her next memory was of being in Ropati's car, in pain, with his "angry face" looming over her.

"That piece of evidence suggests without a doubt she was asleep when the pain was inflicted upon her," he said.

"The medical injuries [to her genitals] show blunt force trauma not consistent with consensual sex."

Earlier in the day, rugby league identity Peter Leitch (The Mad Butcher), told the court Ropati was a gentleman around women.

The trial continues today.