Allegations of Abuse in NZ


Tim Ogle: Home   "A trial that should never have happened"


Page 2 - 2006 (Trial)

 




NZ Herald
November 9 2006; 14:55

Ex-policeman faces big bill after being cleared of rape
NZPA

The former policeman cleared of historic rape charges last night, could face a legal bill of more than $100,000, while his lawyer is raising issues of political involvement.

Tim Ogle, 44, came back from Australia to face the charges after a Far North woman, now 63, said he had handcuffed her and raped her in a Northland police station in 1988.

Last night an Auckland District Court jury took five hours to return not guilty verdicts on seven charges, including four of sexual violation and rape.

Name suppression continued for the woman after the verdict but Ogle asked the court to lift the order suppressing his name.

Today Ogle's lawyer Gary Gotlieb said the case should never have gone ahead and Ogle had had to sell his house to pay his legal costs.

He said the costs included the private investigator they needed to find witnesses for the trial.

Mr Gotlieb also said the case was "too political" after Prime Minister Helen Clark referred the case to the inquiry into police conduct.

He said the case was investigated in 1988 and it was found there was no case to answer.

The woman who claimed she was raped also issued civil proceedings against the Attorney General for not properly investigating it.

"That was dismissed," Mr Gottlieb said.

He said had the Prime Minister not personally referred it to the commission of inquiry, the police would probably not have re-opened the case.

A spokeswoman for Helen Clark said the Prime Minister was en route to London and could not be immediately contacted. She arrives in Britain late tonight.

Previously Helen Clark had said it was entirely a matter for police whether they seek to prosecute, the spokeswoman said.

Mr Gottlieb said there was a huge bill for private investigators and Ogle had to sell his house to met his costs.

"If we hadn't done what we did and had treated it like an ordinary trial, he would have been rolled.

"This is the trouble with anyone. If the state brings its forces against you, it is so bloody hard to stand up to it," Mr Gotlieb said.

Ogle admitted he had sex with the woman but said she had consented.

After the verdict, Ogle said the charges had haunted him for 16 years.

"I've always said I never raped her and the jury showed that that is the case," he said outside the Auckland District Court.

"This has been very hard on my wife, my children and my 82-year-old mother. It's had a terrible impact on all of us but justice has been done.

"I'm just looking forward to spending some time with my wife."