Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

False Allegations - Index

Cases - 2002



NZ Herald
January 16, 2002

False rape complaints irk police

False rape complaints are frustrating and breed suspicion among police, a police officer says.


The experienced officer - who asked not to be named - spoke out yesterday after the latest false sex complaint, which involved a 16-year-old girl who claimed she was abducted from a park at Porirua by three men, blindfolded and taken to an unknown location, where she was raped.

The teenager has since admitted to police that she made up the story and has been referred to Youth Aid.

The officer said a tendency for police to be suspicious about rape complaints was a problem, but understandable after false complaints.

"It's only natural ... You do get far too many of them."

False complaints were also frustrating for investigators.

Police were often reluctant to charge offenders with making false complaints because the lies might have stemmed from personal problems. A court case was unlikely to solve those problems.

Though the motive might be clear and simple with a false burglary complaint - financial gain - it was often more complex with sex crimes. Possible motives were gaining attention, problems at home or a safe way out of an unfaithful liaison.

The officer said there was a concern, however, that false complaints might increase after publicity about ACC payouts for sex crime victims.

Another danger was police putting less effort into solving real crimes because resources were tied up investigating the lie.

Despite concerns about false complaints, the officer said victims should not shy from contacting police.

All reports would be investigated fully