Allegations of Sexual Abuse in NZ

Home / False Allegations /

2008 Cases






Northern Advocate
June 28 2008

15 years' jail for rapes he denies
by Kristin Edge

A Northland man who raped a young girl repeatedly has been jailed for 15 years - but still claims he is innocent.

William Ronald Carey, 43, labourer of Whangarei, was sentenced to 15 years' jail when he appeared in Whangarei District Court yesterday after previously being found guilty by a jury on six charges of sexual violation by rape, two charges of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection and one of indecent assault.

Judge Keith de Ridder said yesterday that Carey must serve a minimum non-parole period of nine years in jail before he was able to be considered for parole.

Defence lawyer Nigel Cook said Carey accepted the verdicts but still believed he was innocent and claimed ``it never happened''.

Judge de Ridder said the offending had happened on many occasions where Carey would get the girl alone and rape her.

One time he had been watching a pornographic video and forced her to perform sexual acts on him.

Judge de Ridder read parts of the victim's impact statement which said she suffered from post traumatic stress syndrome, deep depression, nightmares and at one point she had considered suicide.

``So far I can't find anyone or anything to remove the pain. It is something that will stay with me for life,'' the victim said. ``Your actions have ruined my life.''

Crown prosecutor Peter Magee said it was abhorrent offending over six years and there were no mitigating circumstances in the case. He suggested 15 years was an appropriate starting point.

Judge de Ridder agreed: ``The jury accepted what the victim said. There are no mitigating circumstances, there is no remorse expressed and there are no factors that enable me to decrease the starting point.''

In an unusual step during the sentencing, the judge allowed Carey's sister to read a statement on behalf of the family to the court, without having first checked the letter.

His sister said that in their hearts the family knew he was not guilty and that he had been wrongly convicted.

``The justice system has failed us and now an innocent man is serving a prison term for a crime he did not commit,'' she said.

Judge de Ridder stopped the woman and told her it was not the appropriate forum for the matters to be raised.