Allegations of Abuse in Institutions


St John of God - Marylands - Index


2006/1 - The trial of Bernard McGrath

 




The Press
February 24 2006

Witness makes new abuse claims
by John Henzell

Memories about being sexually abused by Catholic brothers only came back for one man after he read about similar allegations in a newspaper, a High Court jury in Christchurch has been told.

The man says he was aged under eight when he was sodomised once by Bernard Kevin McGrath, a Catholic brother at Marylands boarding school for troubled boys in the 1970s.

But in the witness box at McGrath's trial yesterday, the man came up with new claims of being sexually molested by McGrath on trips away from the school and that he was molested by another Catholic brother.

Quizzed by McGrath's lawyer, Raoul Neave, on the new allegations, he said the first only emerged after the newspaper article and others only surfaced in the past few months while undergoing counselling.

McGrath, 58, denies 53 charges of sodomy and indecency involving 16 boys who had been at the school during his time as a dormitory master and teacher in the mid-1970s.

In a police interview, he denied the boy and his brother, another complainant, had been among his victims, saying he "wasn't attracted to them because they were small kids and he preferred them bigger than that".

McGrath pleaded guilty at the start of the trial to a representative charge of indecency against a 17th boy and the jury has been told he had been jailed for sexually molesting boys at the school.

In the witness box yesterday, the man broke down and cried as he recalled being pushed by McGrath into a bedroom, forced onto the bed, stripped naked, and sodomised.

The court had to take an adjournment while he regained his composure.

"I just remember the abuse. I was really astonished and it really hurt me," he said.

"I just wanted to get out of there. I felt hopeless, like there was nothing I could do. I was told not to tell anyone. If I told, he'd come after me."

He said he told his mother that he did not want to go back to Marylands but did not explain the reason.

Later he turned his back on his mother and brother and tried to put the alleged abuse behind him so he could get on with his life.

However, he raised the abuse with a church worker and later contacted the police after being shown a newspaper article about the allegations at Marylands.

Neave said the first time the man had raised the issue of being pushed into McGrath's bedroom was in court and not in his original police statement.

He said he told police he was pushed, although he accepted it was not in his statement.

"I can't read and write properly. I tried to explain it as best I could," the man added.

The trial continues today.